πOverview of Dispute Resolution Procedures
.
βΆοΈMost contracts contain clauses for claim dispute resolution. The process usually starts with the simplest and quickest procedure then goes in to the next level and so on. Since the court system is lengthy, costly and complicated, other alternative dispute resolution methods have been used. The following methods are usually used in resolving dispute claims.
a)Negotiation: The most direct method for resolving any type of construction dispute. In many cases, the βtruthβ may not be entirely known or acknowledged and βfairnessβ is seen differently by the disputing parties. Negotiation requires certain skills that tend to reduce the gap between the negotiating parties. Although negotiation occurs basically between the disputing parties, independent experts or consultants may be asked to give opinions on certain issues.
b)Mediation: When negotiation does not work, either because of lack of trust or skills, an independent neutral or mediator may get involved to bring the disputing parties together. The mediator can be an individual or a team. The mediator must demonstrate neutrality and patience, and must collect all the facts before making any recommendation. The mediator must be skilled in narrowing the gap between the disputing parties and focusing on the positive side of any proposed solution.
c)Dispute Review Board: Rather than waiting until the end of a project to settle claims, dispute review boards (DRBs) may be used to resolve disputes as they arise on a construction project. An independent neutral panel with construction experience is selected by the owner and contractor when the contract is signed, and the parties agree to call upon the neutral to assist them in resolving dispute during construction.
*Negotiation, mediation and DRBβs are nonbinding. This means the solution changes its shape -like a piece of dough- during the process until it reaches a form acceptable to both parties. No party is under obligation until it accepts the proposed solution.
d)Arbitration: Arbitration is usually a formal process that is performed by an independent professional arbitrator. Arbitration in construction is usually performed by experts in the construction industry such as architects, engineers, or construction management professionals. Although arbitration is usually binding to both parties, arbitrators do not have the enforcement power that judges have.
It should be noted here that in many contracts, arbitration is specified as a binding process if negotiation and mediation fail. As mentioned above, unlike judges arbitrators cannot enforce their judgment. If a party refuses to comply with the arbitratorβs judgment, it may be necessary for the other party to seek a courtβs intervention.
e) Litigation: If the parties cannot reach a settlement by one of the previous processes; the complaining party may sue the other party in a court of the law. The legal process is complex and often involves pri-trial discovery processes such as interrogatories (written questions to the other party) request for the production of documents and pri-trial testimony in depositions. Construction litigation is usually complicated, lengthy and expensive. Many plaintiffs spend more money on attorneyβs fees than they later recover by the courtβs judgment
.
πAvoiding a Dispute
It is far better to avoid a dispute than to have to resolve one. D Some disputes cannot be prevented by prior action, but many can. Ensuring that a formal contract agreement is executed between parties to a contract is a first step towards avoiding disputes. Contractual precautions that provide some safeguard against disputes include ensuring the following things:
β’The parties enter into a finalized contract before work commences;
β’The scope of works is clearly defined prior to tender;
β’The quality constraints are fully defined prior to tender;
β’The conditions of the contract are fair & clear, using standard forms unless non standard provisions are essential.
.
βΆοΈMost contracts contain clauses for claim dispute resolution. The process usually starts with the simplest and quickest procedure then goes in to the next level and so on. Since the court system is lengthy, costly and complicated, other alternative dispute resolution methods have been used. The following methods are usually used in resolving dispute claims.
a)Negotiation: The most direct method for resolving any type of construction dispute. In many cases, the βtruthβ may not be entirely known or acknowledged and βfairnessβ is seen differently by the disputing parties. Negotiation requires certain skills that tend to reduce the gap between the negotiating parties. Although negotiation occurs basically between the disputing parties, independent experts or consultants may be asked to give opinions on certain issues.
b)Mediation: When negotiation does not work, either because of lack of trust or skills, an independent neutral or mediator may get involved to bring the disputing parties together. The mediator can be an individual or a team. The mediator must demonstrate neutrality and patience, and must collect all the facts before making any recommendation. The mediator must be skilled in narrowing the gap between the disputing parties and focusing on the positive side of any proposed solution.
c)Dispute Review Board: Rather than waiting until the end of a project to settle claims, dispute review boards (DRBs) may be used to resolve disputes as they arise on a construction project. An independent neutral panel with construction experience is selected by the owner and contractor when the contract is signed, and the parties agree to call upon the neutral to assist them in resolving dispute during construction.
*Negotiation, mediation and DRBβs are nonbinding. This means the solution changes its shape -like a piece of dough- during the process until it reaches a form acceptable to both parties. No party is under obligation until it accepts the proposed solution.
d)Arbitration: Arbitration is usually a formal process that is performed by an independent professional arbitrator. Arbitration in construction is usually performed by experts in the construction industry such as architects, engineers, or construction management professionals. Although arbitration is usually binding to both parties, arbitrators do not have the enforcement power that judges have.
It should be noted here that in many contracts, arbitration is specified as a binding process if negotiation and mediation fail. As mentioned above, unlike judges arbitrators cannot enforce their judgment. If a party refuses to comply with the arbitratorβs judgment, it may be necessary for the other party to seek a courtβs intervention.
e) Litigation: If the parties cannot reach a settlement by one of the previous processes; the complaining party may sue the other party in a court of the law. The legal process is complex and often involves pri-trial discovery processes such as interrogatories (written questions to the other party) request for the production of documents and pri-trial testimony in depositions. Construction litigation is usually complicated, lengthy and expensive. Many plaintiffs spend more money on attorneyβs fees than they later recover by the courtβs judgment
.
πAvoiding a Dispute
It is far better to avoid a dispute than to have to resolve one. D Some disputes cannot be prevented by prior action, but many can. Ensuring that a formal contract agreement is executed between parties to a contract is a first step towards avoiding disputes. Contractual precautions that provide some safeguard against disputes include ensuring the following things:
β’The parties enter into a finalized contract before work commences;
β’The scope of works is clearly defined prior to tender;
β’The quality constraints are fully defined prior to tender;
β’The conditions of the contract are fair & clear, using standard forms unless non standard provisions are essential.
βΆοΈTODAY GREAT TIP @ETCONp
:
πα α₯αααα»αΉ α α α¨αα½αα αα°α¨α΅ α¨α°αα«α© α¨ PDF αα αααΆα½ α₯αα«αΉ α₯αααα‘α‘
α‘
π Ύα ααα Join α αα¨α α₯α ααα°αα α₯α ααα«αα΅ αα αΌα α«α΅ααα’
α‘
ππππππππππππππ
:
πα α₯αααα»αΉ α α α¨αα½αα αα°α¨α΅ α¨α°αα«α© α¨ PDF αα αααΆα½ α₯αα«αΉ α₯αααα‘α‘
α‘
π Ύα ααα Join α αα¨α α₯α ααα°αα α₯α ααα«αα΅ αα αΌα α«α΅ααα’
α‘
ππππππππππππππ
πFOUNDATION ENGINEERING πππππππ
πSTEEL AND TIMBER ππππππππ