Middle East Spectator — MES
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 BREAKING: Red Alerts in the North @Middle_East_Spectator
Only one missile, intercepted.
❤603🤣267💔87😢57🔥31🤬22👍19🤔12😍9👎8💯8
Tehran.
1🤬1.77K💔225😍201😢92🤣71🔥65😡45❤42🏆22🕊20🤩10
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 BREAKING: Israel targeted the famous high-security 'Evin prison' in Tehran
@Middle_East_Spectator
@Middle_East_Spectator
1🤬1.47K🤣181❤119👎38🍾38🔥34👏27🤯20😱16🍌9👻6
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 BREAKING: Israel targeted the access road to Fordow nuclear site to prevent anyone from approaching
@Middle_East_Spectator
@Middle_East_Spectator
2🤬1.25K🤣194❤87🍌43🔥32🤔27👏22😡14😁12😱6😢1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Tehran.
3🤬1.46K❤141🔥88😢69🤩57😭41👏25🥰19🤨14😱12💯4
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 CONFIRMED: Electrical substation directly hit by Iranian missile in Ashdod
@Middle_East_Spectator
@Middle_East_Spectator
11🥰1.41K❤315🔥238👍88⚡45🤣31😴24🥴20👎15🤬15😐6
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 Some of the Israeli targets in Tehran / Karaj:
– Iranian State TV buildings
– Evin Prison and another prison in Karaj
– Energy Ministry building
– Shaheed Beheshti University
– Police / Basij district offices
@Middle_East_Spectator
– Iranian State TV buildings
– Evin Prison and another prison in Karaj
– Energy Ministry building
– Shaheed Beheshti University
– Police / Basij district offices
@Middle_East_Spectator
2🤬1.38K🔥141❤76👎47💔25👏21😍18👍14😡12🙏6🍓2
Middle East Spectator — MES
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 BREAKING: Israel targeted the access road to Fordow nuclear site to prevent anyone from approaching @Middle_East_Spectator
Israel confirms it targetes the access road to Fordow so no personnel can approach it to assess the damage or inspect.
🤬1.11K👎245❤99🔥55🥴48🤔44💅24😡22💊15😱6🤯5
—❗️🇮🇷/🇷🇺 NEW: Iran's Foreign Minister, Abbas Araqchi, will meet directly with President Putin today
@Middle_East_Spectator
@Middle_East_Spectator
❤1.22K👍236🤣79🔥59🍌32🐳16😴15👎13🥰11🤝9🤔5
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
❤1.76K👏201🍌149👍126🤣49🥴35🔥30🤝26🗿21🤬14👻10
— MUST READ: Very good thread by Dr. Jeffrey Lewis, professor at Middlebury Institute & Non-Proliferation Studies.
He notes Iran likely retains all of its ~400kg 60% uranium stockpile, as well as 1-2 undeclared underground facilities that are located as deep (possibly deeper) than Fordow which have not been bombed yet. Says Iran can rush towards a bomb within 5 months even after current events.
https://x.com/armscontrolwonk/status/1936955686174466551?s=46
He notes Iran likely retains all of its ~400kg 60% uranium stockpile, as well as 1-2 undeclared underground facilities that are located as deep (possibly deeper) than Fordow which have not been bombed yet. Says Iran can rush towards a bomb within 5 months even after current events.
https://x.com/armscontrolwonk/status/1936955686174466551?s=46
X (formerly Twitter)
Dr. Jeffrey Lewis (@ArmsControlWonk) on X
Why am I so unimpressed by these strikes? Israel and the US have failed to target significant elements of Iran's nuclear materials and production infrastructure. RISING LION and MIDNIGHT HAMMER are tactically brilliant, but may turn out to be strategic failures.…
👏697👍155❤123🍌26😴23🥴17❤🔥15👎11🌭8😁6👻4
Middle East Spectator — MES
— MUST READ: Very good thread by Dr. Jeffrey Lewis, professor at Middlebury Institute & Non-Proliferation Studies. He notes Iran likely retains all of its ~400kg 60% uranium stockpile, as well as 1-2 undeclared underground facilities that are located as deep…
—❗️🇮🇷☢️ Dr. Jeffrey Lewis, Professor at Middlebury Institute & Staff at James Martin Center of Non-Proliferation Studies:
'Why am I so unimpressed by these strikes? Israel and the U.S. have failed to target significant elements of Iran's nuclear materials and production infrastructure. RISING LION and MIDNIGHT HAMMER are tactically brilliant, but may turn out to be strategic failures.
Netanyahu's justification for conducting this strike was that 'Iran has produced enough highly enriched uranium for nine atom bombs — nine.' He refers to Iran's stockpile of ~400 kg of 60% U-235 which, if further enriched, would be enough for 9-10 weapons. Let's consider.
The 400kg of HEU was largely stored in underground tunnels near the Isfahan Uranium Conversion Facility. Despite extensive Israeli and U.S. attacks on the facility, there does not seem to have been any effort to destroy these tunnels or the material that was in them.
No one even knows where the HEU is now! Rafael Grossi says Iran moved it. Marco Rubio says 'nothing can move' in Iran. But trucks are moving in Iran. Trucks and heavy equipment showed up at least two days ago to seal the tunnels to protect them, and there is visual evidence of this. Trucks also showed up at the Fordow FEP the day before the strike, possibly to relocate sensitive equipment, and certainly to cover those entrances with dirt. Iran just isn't a no-drive zone at the moment.
To be fair, some in the Trump admin do acknowledge Iran still has the enriched material. J.D. Vance says they're going to 'have conversations with the Iranians about' it. 🙃
The talking point is that the U.S. has knocked out Iran's ability to further enrich it and convert it to metal, so 'its fine'.
IT'S NOT FINE. Yes, the strikes on the enrichment plants at Qom (Fordow FEP) and Natanz (PFEP and FEP) appear successful. But there has been no effort to strike the enormous underground facility next to Natanz where Iran can make more centrifuges and maybe do other things.
In 2022, Iran moved a centrifuge production line to the heart of the mountain there. This facility is huge — we estimated 10,000 m2 or more — and we don't really know what else it might house (like enrichment or conversion).
Also, Iran recently announced a 'new enrichment facility in a secure location' and told the IAEA it was ready to start installing centrifuges. The IAEA was set to inspect the facility, near Isfahan, before the bombing. It hasn't been bombed AFAIK.
This means Iran has retained 400 kg of 60% HEU, the ability to manufacture centrifuges, and one, possibly two underground enrichment sites. That is also to say nothing of possible secret sites, which opponents of the JCPOA used to invoke all the freaking time.
Let's say Iran decides to rush a bomb. Iran can install ~1.5 cascades a week. In six weeks, it could have 9 cascades of IR-6 machines. It would take those machines about 60 days to enrich all 400 kg to WGU. Altogether that's about five months although IMMV.
RISING LION and MIDNIGHT HAMMER have not slowed the Iranian program nearly as much as the JCPOA. We hold diplomacy to much higher standards than bombing.
The same people who endlessly complained about the JCPOA 'sunsetting' are now happy to delay Iran's bomb by much less. The real purpose was always regime change.'
@Middle_East_Spectator
'Why am I so unimpressed by these strikes? Israel and the U.S. have failed to target significant elements of Iran's nuclear materials and production infrastructure. RISING LION and MIDNIGHT HAMMER are tactically brilliant, but may turn out to be strategic failures.
Netanyahu's justification for conducting this strike was that 'Iran has produced enough highly enriched uranium for nine atom bombs — nine.' He refers to Iran's stockpile of ~400 kg of 60% U-235 which, if further enriched, would be enough for 9-10 weapons. Let's consider.
The 400kg of HEU was largely stored in underground tunnels near the Isfahan Uranium Conversion Facility. Despite extensive Israeli and U.S. attacks on the facility, there does not seem to have been any effort to destroy these tunnels or the material that was in them.
No one even knows where the HEU is now! Rafael Grossi says Iran moved it. Marco Rubio says 'nothing can move' in Iran. But trucks are moving in Iran. Trucks and heavy equipment showed up at least two days ago to seal the tunnels to protect them, and there is visual evidence of this. Trucks also showed up at the Fordow FEP the day before the strike, possibly to relocate sensitive equipment, and certainly to cover those entrances with dirt. Iran just isn't a no-drive zone at the moment.
To be fair, some in the Trump admin do acknowledge Iran still has the enriched material. J.D. Vance says they're going to 'have conversations with the Iranians about' it. 🙃
The talking point is that the U.S. has knocked out Iran's ability to further enrich it and convert it to metal, so 'its fine'.
IT'S NOT FINE. Yes, the strikes on the enrichment plants at Qom (Fordow FEP) and Natanz (PFEP and FEP) appear successful. But there has been no effort to strike the enormous underground facility next to Natanz where Iran can make more centrifuges and maybe do other things.
In 2022, Iran moved a centrifuge production line to the heart of the mountain there. This facility is huge — we estimated 10,000 m2 or more — and we don't really know what else it might house (like enrichment or conversion).
Also, Iran recently announced a 'new enrichment facility in a secure location' and told the IAEA it was ready to start installing centrifuges. The IAEA was set to inspect the facility, near Isfahan, before the bombing. It hasn't been bombed AFAIK.
This means Iran has retained 400 kg of 60% HEU, the ability to manufacture centrifuges, and one, possibly two underground enrichment sites. That is also to say nothing of possible secret sites, which opponents of the JCPOA used to invoke all the freaking time.
Let's say Iran decides to rush a bomb. Iran can install ~1.5 cascades a week. In six weeks, it could have 9 cascades of IR-6 machines. It would take those machines about 60 days to enrich all 400 kg to WGU. Altogether that's about five months although IMMV.
RISING LION and MIDNIGHT HAMMER have not slowed the Iranian program nearly as much as the JCPOA. We hold diplomacy to much higher standards than bombing.
The same people who endlessly complained about the JCPOA 'sunsetting' are now happy to delay Iran's bomb by much less. The real purpose was always regime change.'
@Middle_East_Spectator
❤945👍210🤣107✍29🤪20🤨19🔥10🤷♂9🥴8👎6🎄3
Middle East Spectator — MES
—❗️🇮🇷☢️ Dr. Jeffrey Lewis, Professor at Middlebury Institute & Staff at James Martin Center of Non-Proliferation Studies: 'Why am I so unimpressed by these strikes? Israel and the U.S. have failed to target significant elements of Iran's nuclear materials…
TLDR:
– Iran still has its ~400kg of 60% enriched uranium, nobody knows where it is.
– Underground complex in Isfahan, which likely stored some uranium, was not struck.
– Iran still has one huge (10,000m2) new underground nuclear site near Natanz that was not attacked, centrifuges can be installed here and enrichment can resume. It's likely DEEPER than even Fordow itself.
– Likely one or two more undeclared sites throughout the country that could be re-equipped for rapid enrichment.
– Iran's existing stockpile of ~400kg HEU can be enriched to weapons-grade (90%) uranium within 2 months, bombs can be made within 5 months (if desired).
@Middle_East_Spectator
– Iran still has its ~400kg of 60% enriched uranium, nobody knows where it is.
– Underground complex in Isfahan, which likely stored some uranium, was not struck.
– Iran still has one huge (10,000m2) new underground nuclear site near Natanz that was not attacked, centrifuges can be installed here and enrichment can resume. It's likely DEEPER than even Fordow itself.
– Likely one or two more undeclared sites throughout the country that could be re-equipped for rapid enrichment.
– Iran's existing stockpile of ~400kg HEU can be enriched to weapons-grade (90%) uranium within 2 months, bombs can be made within 5 months (if desired).
@Middle_East_Spectator
❤973👍214🤣88🥴28🤔16🦄16🎅8🙉8🤷8😁5🤨5
—❗️🇮🇱/🇮🇷 WATCH: Iranian air defenses shot down an Israeli 'Hermes-900' drone over Western Iran this morning
@Middle_East_Spectator
@Middle_East_Spectator
❤936🔥223👏100👍46😴28🤣16🥰12🤬10💔2🎄2😭1