Forwarded from Zornkrieger
Withdrawing from Kherson:
Pros -
1. Youโre not dealing with supply issues of relying on pontoons and bridges that are being targeted every other day
2. The manpower needed to defend the Dnieper river will be much less than to defend Kherson
3. You free up assets for an attack in the Donbas
4. You secure a flank with the Dnieper river as your barrier
5. Narrowing the frontline, which favors the side with less manpower and more artillery (Added)
6. Prevents the destruction of Kherson city if the Ukrainians were to succeed in an offensive (Added)
7. Prolongs the stalemate situation until the Russian mobilized arrive (Added)
Cons -
1. Major political defeat, losing a capitol city of one of the new territories
2. Ukrainians now free up forces to be used in the Donbas
3. Ukraine secures their flank
4. You lose a strategic bridgehead across the Dneiper that wonโt be easy to get back
5. Potential of increased support from the West in aid and equipment (Added)
6. Ranged systems like HIMARS can now potentially strike targets in Crimea (Added)
7. Potential threat of internal unrest (Added)
8. International perspective of Russia may be altered (Added)
9. Ukrainian war crimes, war crimes propaganda by the Ukrainians, on remaining civilians that refused to evacuate (Added)
10. Morale boost to Ukrainians, decreased morale on the Russian side (Added)
Pros -
1. Youโre not dealing with supply issues of relying on pontoons and bridges that are being targeted every other day
2. The manpower needed to defend the Dnieper river will be much less than to defend Kherson
3. You free up assets for an attack in the Donbas
4. You secure a flank with the Dnieper river as your barrier
5. Narrowing the frontline, which favors the side with less manpower and more artillery (Added)
6. Prevents the destruction of Kherson city if the Ukrainians were to succeed in an offensive (Added)
7. Prolongs the stalemate situation until the Russian mobilized arrive (Added)
Cons -
1. Major political defeat, losing a capitol city of one of the new territories
2. Ukrainians now free up forces to be used in the Donbas
3. Ukraine secures their flank
4. You lose a strategic bridgehead across the Dneiper that wonโt be easy to get back
5. Potential of increased support from the West in aid and equipment (Added)
6. Ranged systems like HIMARS can now potentially strike targets in Crimea (Added)
7. Potential threat of internal unrest (Added)
8. International perspective of Russia may be altered (Added)
9. Ukrainian war crimes, war crimes propaganda by the Ukrainians, on remaining civilians that refused to evacuate (Added)
10. Morale boost to Ukrainians, decreased morale on the Russian side (Added)
๐189๐32๐ค17๐คก13๐6๐คฌ6๐ฅฑ6๐ฅ2๐ฉ1๐ฏ1๐คฃ1
โก ๐ฌ๐งTens of thousands of British government workers have voted in favour of taking strike action over pay, pensions and redundancy terms, the Public and Commercial Services (PCS) union said on Thursday.
Union general secretary Mark Serwotka said: โWe are calling on the government to respond positively to our membersโ demands. Our members have spoken and if the government fails to listen to them, weโll have no option than to launch a prolonged programme of industrial action reaching into every corner of public life.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
Union general secretary Mark Serwotka said: โWe are calling on the government to respond positively to our membersโ demands. Our members have spoken and if the government fails to listen to them, weโll have no option than to launch a prolonged programme of industrial action reaching into every corner of public life.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐130๐24๐คก7๐ฅฑ7๐6โค5๐ฅ3๐ด2๐1๐1
Forwarded from SITREP - Independent OSINT Channel
โก๏ธ Russian Defence Ministry report on the progress of the special military operation in Ukraineโก๏ธ
(10 November 2022)
โฝ๏ธ The Armed Forces of the Russian Federation continue the special military operation.
โฝ๏ธ In Nikolayev-Krivoy Rog direction, the manoeuvre of Russian troops to the prepared positions on the left bank of the Dnepr River is under way, in strict accordance with the approved plan.
๐ฅIn Kupyansk direction, the enemy with up to two companies reinforced by nationalists and foreign mercenaries made unsuccessful attempts to attack units of Russian troops in direction of Kuzyomovka (Lugansk People's Republic). Through the active action of our troops and artillery fire, the enemy units were stopped and dispersed on the far approaches to the defence line. Over 90 Ukrainian personnel, one tank, and four armoured fighting vehicles have been eliminated.
๐ฅIn Krasny Liman direction, Russian troops thwarted an attempt by two reinforced platoons of the AFU to attack Stelmakhovka and Ploshchanka (Lugansk People's Republic). As a result of the shelling, the enemy's losses were 70 Ukrainian servicemen killed and wounded, one infantry fighting vehicle, and three pickup trucks.
๐ฅIn South Donetsk direction, a counterattack by AFU units has been repulsed near Nikolskoye (Donetsk People's Republic). Russian artillery and army aviation destroyed up to 55 fighters, one tank, and two armoured fighting vehicles.
๐ฅOperational-Tactical and Army Aviation, Missile Troops and Artillery has hit two command posts of the AFU and foreign mercenaries near Nikolayev and Sukhoi Stavok (Kherson region), as well as 46 artillery units in firing positions, manpower and military equipment in 153 areas.
๐ฅThree US-made AN/TPQ-50 counter-battery radar stations have been destroyed near Krasny Liman (Donetsk People's Republic), Novogrigorovka (Kherson region), and Novopoltavka (Nikolayev region). The AFU fuel depot has been destroyed near Annovka (Dnepropetrovsk region). The AFU munitions depot of artillery was destroyed near Novoaleksandrovka, (Nikolayev region).
๐ฅA Su-25 aircraft of the AFU has been shot down by Russian Aerospace Forces fighter aircraft near Malomikhailovskoye (Nikolayev region). A Ukrainian Mi-8 helicopter has been neutralised near Rizdvyanka (Zaporozhye region).
๐ฅ Nine unmanned aerial vehicles were shot down by air defence forces near Golikovo and Chervonopopovka (Lugansk People's Republic), Kirillovka, Yegorovka, and Novoandreyevka (Donetsk People's Republic), Vasilyevka (Zaporozhye region), and Veseloye and Krynki (Kherson region).
โฝ๏ธIn addition, 21 HIMARS and Olkha multiple-launch rocket systems were intercepted near Vysokoye, Tomarino, Antonovka, Nikolskoye, and Novaya Kakhovka (Kherson region), as well as three HARM anti-radiation missile near Guselskoye (Donetsk People's Republic), Nikolskoye and Korsunka (Kherson region).
#MoD #Russia #Ukraine #report
t.me/sitreports /@mod_russia_en/
Join SITREP๐บMap Reports - Top Videos - Analyses
(10 November 2022)
โฝ๏ธ The Armed Forces of the Russian Federation continue the special military operation.
โฝ๏ธ In Nikolayev-Krivoy Rog direction, the manoeuvre of Russian troops to the prepared positions on the left bank of the Dnepr River is under way, in strict accordance with the approved plan.
๐ฅIn Kupyansk direction, the enemy with up to two companies reinforced by nationalists and foreign mercenaries made unsuccessful attempts to attack units of Russian troops in direction of Kuzyomovka (Lugansk People's Republic). Through the active action of our troops and artillery fire, the enemy units were stopped and dispersed on the far approaches to the defence line. Over 90 Ukrainian personnel, one tank, and four armoured fighting vehicles have been eliminated.
๐ฅIn Krasny Liman direction, Russian troops thwarted an attempt by two reinforced platoons of the AFU to attack Stelmakhovka and Ploshchanka (Lugansk People's Republic). As a result of the shelling, the enemy's losses were 70 Ukrainian servicemen killed and wounded, one infantry fighting vehicle, and three pickup trucks.
๐ฅIn South Donetsk direction, a counterattack by AFU units has been repulsed near Nikolskoye (Donetsk People's Republic). Russian artillery and army aviation destroyed up to 55 fighters, one tank, and two armoured fighting vehicles.
๐ฅOperational-Tactical and Army Aviation, Missile Troops and Artillery has hit two command posts of the AFU and foreign mercenaries near Nikolayev and Sukhoi Stavok (Kherson region), as well as 46 artillery units in firing positions, manpower and military equipment in 153 areas.
๐ฅThree US-made AN/TPQ-50 counter-battery radar stations have been destroyed near Krasny Liman (Donetsk People's Republic), Novogrigorovka (Kherson region), and Novopoltavka (Nikolayev region). The AFU fuel depot has been destroyed near Annovka (Dnepropetrovsk region). The AFU munitions depot of artillery was destroyed near Novoaleksandrovka, (Nikolayev region).
๐ฅA Su-25 aircraft of the AFU has been shot down by Russian Aerospace Forces fighter aircraft near Malomikhailovskoye (Nikolayev region). A Ukrainian Mi-8 helicopter has been neutralised near Rizdvyanka (Zaporozhye region).
๐ฅ Nine unmanned aerial vehicles were shot down by air defence forces near Golikovo and Chervonopopovka (Lugansk People's Republic), Kirillovka, Yegorovka, and Novoandreyevka (Donetsk People's Republic), Vasilyevka (Zaporozhye region), and Veseloye and Krynki (Kherson region).
โฝ๏ธIn addition, 21 HIMARS and Olkha multiple-launch rocket systems were intercepted near Vysokoye, Tomarino, Antonovka, Nikolskoye, and Novaya Kakhovka (Kherson region), as well as three HARM anti-radiation missile near Guselskoye (Donetsk People's Republic), Nikolskoye and Korsunka (Kherson region).
#MoD #Russia #Ukraine #report
t.me/sitreports /@mod_russia_en/
Join SITREP๐บMap Reports - Top Videos - Analyses
Telegram
MoD Russia
#MoD #Russia #Ukraine #report
@mod_russia_en
@mod_russia_en
๐89๐ฅฑ21๐ฉ8๐ฅ6๐3๐คก3๐2โค1
I trust the #LiveStream was informative.
The reason for the lengthy answers is that no question that was asked had an easy one. And it would be disingenuous of me to pretend otherwise. If you are able to answer any of these questions with a pithy quip, then you are ready for prime time.
Any constructive proposals are welcome here.
The reason for the lengthy answers is that no question that was asked had an easy one. And it would be disingenuous of me to pretend otherwise. If you are able to answer any of these questions with a pithy quip, then you are ready for prime time.
Any constructive proposals are welcome here.
๐110๐ฅฑ13โค6๐คก5๐5๐3๐2๐ฅ2
Forwarded from Fearless John - @European_dissident
โพSpanish military will train Ukrainian snipers.
-This will take place at a military base in Toledo under a program that provides for the training of 400 troops every two months.
โพIn April of this year spanish Nazis linked to the Azov Battalion asked for funds for the sniper who planned to kill Pedro Sรกnchez, president of the Spanish government.
-Manuel Murillo, who sought help in WhatsApp groups to assassinate the Prime Minister, had been participating since March 2018 in meetings of the Nazi National Identity Front (FNI) party, led by a former Spanish military officer and associated with Ukrainian paramilitaries and Polish and Italian ultras. After his arrest, the party raised funds for "legal defense" also among their European allies including Azov.
โพWhat could go wrong when you are training people who previously have supported other people who plotted your own murder? I'm not sure Spanish president Pedro Sanchez has thought this properly.
โพFollow:
https://t.me/UkraineHumanRightsAbuses
-This will take place at a military base in Toledo under a program that provides for the training of 400 troops every two months.
โพIn April of this year spanish Nazis linked to the Azov Battalion asked for funds for the sniper who planned to kill Pedro Sรกnchez, president of the Spanish government.
-Manuel Murillo, who sought help in WhatsApp groups to assassinate the Prime Minister, had been participating since March 2018 in meetings of the Nazi National Identity Front (FNI) party, led by a former Spanish military officer and associated with Ukrainian paramilitaries and Polish and Italian ultras. After his arrest, the party raised funds for "legal defense" also among their European allies including Azov.
โพWhat could go wrong when you are training people who previously have supported other people who plotted your own murder? I'm not sure Spanish president Pedro Sanchez has thought this properly.
โพFollow:
https://t.me/UkraineHumanRightsAbuses
๐คก143๐คฌ48๐คฎ24๐17โค4๐ฅฑ4
Russian Federation flag has been hoisted over Pavlovka, which is once again under the control of the Russian Army.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐186โค51๐ฅฑ25๐ฅ7๐4๐1๐ฉ1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
โก๏ธ๐ท๐บ๐บ๐ฆ๐ฅ #Donbass - Ukrainian BMP hit near #Ugledarโก๏ธ
A Russian UAV detected a Ukrainian BMP-1 armoured personnel carrier moving into position: the enemy was planning to open fire on the western outskirts of #Vladimirovka.
The BMP that had reached the opening fire point was hit by a high-precision ammunition from an artillery crew of the Russian Armed Forces.
Most likely, a Krasnopol corrective projectile was used to incapacitate the enemy's equipment.
Coordinates: 47.779928, 37.374942
t.me/Slavyangrad /@rybar/@sitreports/#vid/
Join SLG๐บIntelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
A Russian UAV detected a Ukrainian BMP-1 armoured personnel carrier moving into position: the enemy was planning to open fire on the western outskirts of #Vladimirovka.
The BMP that had reached the opening fire point was hit by a high-precision ammunition from an artillery crew of the Russian Armed Forces.
Most likely, a Krasnopol corrective projectile was used to incapacitate the enemy's equipment.
Coordinates: 47.779928, 37.374942
t.me/Slavyangrad /@rybar/@sitreports/#vid/
Join SLG๐บIntelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐94๐ฅฑ10โก7๐ฅ3๐3๐ฅฐ1
The adviser to the head of the Ukrainian President's office ,M. Podolyak is lying ๐คฅ. According to local reports - a complete retarded lie, there was no mass mining of apartments.
- Anatoly Shariy
-Ukraina_ru
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
- Anatoly Shariy
-Ukraina_ru
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐คก163๐11๐11๐คฎ11๐ฅฑ7๐ฉ4๐2๐ฅ1๐ค1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
โก๏ธ๐ท๐บ๐บ๐ฆ๐ฅ #Donbass - Russian Grad MLRS firing on AFU positions in #Georgievkaโก๏ธ
The footage from the Tankers of the Southern Military District by @tankist4 depicts Russian Grad multiple-launch rocket system operating on the village of #Georgievka, located near the strategically important village of #Maryinka.
Judging by the area where the private sector was hit, the strike targeted a concentration of the enemy's personnel and equipment in #Georgievka.
There is intense fighting in #Maryinka itself. Assault units of the Russian Armed Forces and DPR People's Militia are advancing towards Druzhba Avenue. The western part of the settlement is still under the control of the AFU.
Coordinates: 47.961851, 37.447370
t.me/Slavyangrad /@rybar/@sitreports/#vid/
Join SLG๐บIntelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
The footage from the Tankers of the Southern Military District by @tankist4 depicts Russian Grad multiple-launch rocket system operating on the village of #Georgievka, located near the strategically important village of #Maryinka.
Judging by the area where the private sector was hit, the strike targeted a concentration of the enemy's personnel and equipment in #Georgievka.
There is intense fighting in #Maryinka itself. Assault units of the Russian Armed Forces and DPR People's Militia are advancing towards Druzhba Avenue. The western part of the settlement is still under the control of the AFU.
Coordinates: 47.961851, 37.447370
t.me/Slavyangrad /@rybar/@sitreports/#vid/
Join SLG๐บIntelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐ฅ73๐16๐ฅฑ8
What happens if Russia withdraws? - CNN
If and when Russian troops do withdraw to the east bank, their supply lines will become easier and they will regain defense in depth. Any attempt by Ukrainian forces to cross the Dnipro would be costly to the point of prohibitive.
Russia would retain control of 60 per cent of the Kherson region, including the coastline along the Sea of Azov. So long as Moscow's troops control and fortify the Dnipro's east bank, Ukrainian forces will struggle to damage or disrupt the canal that carries fresh water to Crimea.
Surovikin's priority appears to be stabilizing Russia's defensive lines after a difficult few months. He made the point on Wednesday that the forces being pulled out of Kherson "will be used for active operations, including offensive ones, in other directions in the operation zone."
There is always a chance that the Moscow meeting on Wednesday was designed to lure Ukrainian forces into a trap, and that the Russians don't intend to abandon the west bank altogether. Senior Ukrainian officials have certainly been skeptical.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
If and when Russian troops do withdraw to the east bank, their supply lines will become easier and they will regain defense in depth. Any attempt by Ukrainian forces to cross the Dnipro would be costly to the point of prohibitive.
Russia would retain control of 60 per cent of the Kherson region, including the coastline along the Sea of Azov. So long as Moscow's troops control and fortify the Dnipro's east bank, Ukrainian forces will struggle to damage or disrupt the canal that carries fresh water to Crimea.
Surovikin's priority appears to be stabilizing Russia's defensive lines after a difficult few months. He made the point on Wednesday that the forces being pulled out of Kherson "will be used for active operations, including offensive ones, in other directions in the operation zone."
There is always a chance that the Moscow meeting on Wednesday was designed to lure Ukrainian forces into a trap, and that the Russians don't intend to abandon the west bank altogether. Senior Ukrainian officials have certainly been skeptical.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐148๐ฉ20๐ค18๐8๐ฅฑ7๐ฅ1
Forwarded from SITREP - Independent OSINT Channel
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
โก๏ธ๐ท๐บ๐บ๐ฆ๐ฏ Battle for #Donbass - #Kaskad on the Huntโก๏ธ
Nazis are not welcome in the #Donbass. Servicemen of the DPR OBTF 'Kaskad' successfully identify and destroy the henchmen of the #Kiev regime in the #Ugledar direction.
โ ๏ธ
Join SITREP๐บMap Reports - Top Videos - Analyses
Nazis are not welcome in the #Donbass. Servicemen of the DPR OBTF 'Kaskad' successfully identify and destroy the henchmen of the #Kiev regime in the #Ugledar direction.
โ ๏ธ
Verbatim Translation
t.me/sitreports /@obtf_kaskad/#vid/Join SITREP๐บMap Reports - Top Videos - Analyses
๐ฅฐ75๐40๐ฅ8๐ฉ4๐3๐ข1๐คก1๐1
Forwarded from Fearless John - @European_dissident
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
โพA Ukrainian POW said the Ukrainian government doesnโt pay money to the families of the missing and dead soldiers, as the commanders write them down as deserters.
โพFollow:
https://t.me/UkraineHumanRightsAbuses
โพFollow:
https://t.me/UkraineHumanRightsAbuses
๐101๐คฏ32๐คฃ14๐ข12๐คฎ12๐8๐ฅด6๐คก3๐ฅฑ2
โ๏ธNorway to give 1.5 billion kroner ( $147 million) to Ukraine.
โThe Norwegian government is preparing to allocate approximately 1.5 billion crowns to the UK-organized international fund to support Ukraine. This will be in addition to the 400 million kroner that Norway previously donated to the fund," Norwegian Defense Minister Bjorn Arild Graham said in a statement on the Norwegian government's website.
RT
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
โThe Norwegian government is preparing to allocate approximately 1.5 billion crowns to the UK-organized international fund to support Ukraine. This will be in addition to the 400 million kroner that Norway previously donated to the fund," Norwegian Defense Minister Bjorn Arild Graham said in a statement on the Norwegian government's website.
RT
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐ฉ148๐คฎ43๐คฌ20๐12๐ฅฑ7๐คก6๐ฅ2๐คฏ2
Forwarded from SITREP - Independent OSINT Channel
โก๏ธ๐ท๐บ๐บ๐ฆโ๏ธ Situation in the #Ugledar Direction until 18:00 on 10 Nov 2022โก๏ธ
๐ฉธ Late in the afternoon, information emerged that the village of #Pavlovka had come fully under the control of the Russian Armed Forces. According to other sources, the AFU withdrew from the settlement but retained control of the northern approaches to the village.
The Russian Armed Forces first liberated the settlement back in the spring. In June, Ukrainian formations recaptured the village and in late October Russian forces launched a counteroffensive against the lost positions.
โช๏ธ Fighting for #Pavlovka lasted several weeks, with units of the Pacific Fleet Brigade and the DPR OBTF suffered losses in personnel and equipment during the clashes.
โช๏ธ However, Russian forces also managed to inflict heavy damage on the enemy, including the active use of Lancet and Kub loitering munitions, which disabled enemy artillery in the near rear and hit personnel in #Pavlovka itself.
โช๏ธ There were no changes in the front line in other sections. There are skirmishes and exchanges of artillery fire near #Prechistovka and #Novomikhailovka, but no active offensive actions are being taken by the Russian Armed Forces.
t.me/sitreports / t.me/rybar/41043 /#smo/
Join SITREP๐บMap Reports - Top Videos - Analyses
๐ฉธ Late in the afternoon, information emerged that the village of #Pavlovka had come fully under the control of the Russian Armed Forces. According to other sources, the AFU withdrew from the settlement but retained control of the northern approaches to the village.
The Russian Armed Forces first liberated the settlement back in the spring. In June, Ukrainian formations recaptured the village and in late October Russian forces launched a counteroffensive against the lost positions.
โช๏ธ Fighting for #Pavlovka lasted several weeks, with units of the Pacific Fleet Brigade and the DPR OBTF suffered losses in personnel and equipment during the clashes.
โช๏ธ However, Russian forces also managed to inflict heavy damage on the enemy, including the active use of Lancet and Kub loitering munitions, which disabled enemy artillery in the near rear and hit personnel in #Pavlovka itself.
โช๏ธ There were no changes in the front line in other sections. There are skirmishes and exchanges of artillery fire near #Prechistovka and #Novomikhailovka, but no active offensive actions are being taken by the Russian Armed Forces.
t.me/sitreports / t.me/rybar/41043 /#smo/
Join SITREP๐บMap Reports - Top Videos - Analyses
Telegram
MAP:
Ugledar Direction at 18:00 on 10 Nov 2022
๐พ76๐50๐9๐ฅ5๐คก4๐1
๐จ๐ฌ Congolese Foreign Minister Blasts Grain Supplies to Europe Instead of Africa as 'Hypocrisy'
"We have found out that... the majority of ships transporting Ukrainian wheat have been heading to European ports, and not to the ports of countries where, as they have said, a catastrophe will happen... There is a lot of hypocrisy in our world," Jean-Claude Gakosso told Sputnik.
โ๏ธAt the same time, talks about the fact Africans will die of starvation is an example of propaganda, the Congolese foreign minister emphasized.
-Sputnik
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
"We have found out that... the majority of ships transporting Ukrainian wheat have been heading to European ports, and not to the ports of countries where, as they have said, a catastrophe will happen... There is a lot of hypocrisy in our world," Jean-Claude Gakosso told Sputnik.
โ๏ธAt the same time, talks about the fact Africans will die of starvation is an example of propaganda, the Congolese foreign minister emphasized.
-Sputnik
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐149๐27๐ฅ13๐4๐ฅฑ3๐ฑ2๐ฅฐ1๐คก1๐1
The Military Necessity of Kherson Withdrawal
@Svarschiki writes:
From a military point of view, the decision to abandon the territory on the right bank of the Dnieper is correct: If there are no forces and no opportunity to attack Nikolaev, if the group's supply through the Dnieper is constantly under the fire control of the Ukrainian army, it is better to withdraw to the previously prepared defensive lines and preserve the group's combat effectiveness.
Kherson and the left bank of the Dnieper have no independent strategic significance at this stage [GB: presumably the author means that this is so because of lack of troops to continue an offensive in the direction of Nikolayev or Krivoy Rog. Even in this case, the lack of strategic significance can only be argued in the short to intermediate term.]
In the current situation, the planned operation to take the troops to the most advantageous line is a military expediency, even a dire necessity.
The organized withdrawal of units to the defensive line Sofievka - Klapaya-Baratovka - Tavriyskoye - Kostyrka - Chervonyi Mayak and the transition to strategic defence is dictated by the need to maintain the combat effectiveness of the HQ on the Nikolay-Krivoy Rog direction, as well as the opportunity to activate the released forces to begin active combat operations on the Donetsk direction.
The command has no reserves prepared for active operations in the Nikolayev-Krivoy Rog direction that could be additionally redeployed. It is not possible to withdraw troops from other directions. And the preparation of new units and formations in any case will take another 2-3 weeks, and this is with the most primitive approach, without the combat readiness of the units.
In the current situation, in our opinion, the command of the Russian Armed Forces has made the only correct decision. Because if the withdrawal of the occupied territory is inevitable anyway, it is better to do so without being defeated by the enemy's troops and then being forced to retreat anyways. We will need the troops yetโthe war will be long. The fact that the forced withdrawal of troops from the liberated territory, previously paid for with the lives of soldiers and officers, still takes place is a bitter fact, but not a fatal one.
At the moment, the withdrawal of troops from the right bank of the Dnieper is a direct adherence to military necessity, which is often diametrically opposed to political expediency.
PS. The opinion above is provided for reflection and consideration, not necessarily because @Slavyangrad agrees or disagrees with its postulates.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
@Svarschiki writes:
From a military point of view, the decision to abandon the territory on the right bank of the Dnieper is correct: If there are no forces and no opportunity to attack Nikolaev, if the group's supply through the Dnieper is constantly under the fire control of the Ukrainian army, it is better to withdraw to the previously prepared defensive lines and preserve the group's combat effectiveness.
Kherson and the left bank of the Dnieper have no independent strategic significance at this stage [GB: presumably the author means that this is so because of lack of troops to continue an offensive in the direction of Nikolayev or Krivoy Rog. Even in this case, the lack of strategic significance can only be argued in the short to intermediate term.]
In the current situation, the planned operation to take the troops to the most advantageous line is a military expediency, even a dire necessity.
The organized withdrawal of units to the defensive line Sofievka - Klapaya-Baratovka - Tavriyskoye - Kostyrka - Chervonyi Mayak and the transition to strategic defence is dictated by the need to maintain the combat effectiveness of the HQ on the Nikolay-Krivoy Rog direction, as well as the opportunity to activate the released forces to begin active combat operations on the Donetsk direction.
The command has no reserves prepared for active operations in the Nikolayev-Krivoy Rog direction that could be additionally redeployed. It is not possible to withdraw troops from other directions. And the preparation of new units and formations in any case will take another 2-3 weeks, and this is with the most primitive approach, without the combat readiness of the units.
In the current situation, in our opinion, the command of the Russian Armed Forces has made the only correct decision. Because if the withdrawal of the occupied territory is inevitable anyway, it is better to do so without being defeated by the enemy's troops and then being forced to retreat anyways. We will need the troops yetโthe war will be long. The fact that the forced withdrawal of troops from the liberated territory, previously paid for with the lives of soldiers and officers, still takes place is a bitter fact, but not a fatal one.
At the moment, the withdrawal of troops from the right bank of the Dnieper is a direct adherence to military necessity, which is often diametrically opposed to political expediency.
PS. The opinion above is provided for reflection and consideration, not necessarily because @Slavyangrad agrees or disagrees with its postulates.
Join Slavyangrad
@Slavyangrad
Join SLG ๐บ Intelligence Briefings, Strategy and Analysis, Expert Community
๐142๐คก38๐11๐9๐ค8โค3๐คฌ3๐ฉ3๐ฅ2๐คฃ2๐1