Answers
โโโ
a) The doctor in this case is facing a conflict between the wife's interest of keeping her
family history secret to save her marriage vs the principles of non-maleficence and
beneficence; to do the best for the upcoming baby.
b) To solve this dilemma, we should ask ourselves 5 ques to know whether the action is
ethical or not:
- What benefit and what harm will this action produce?
- Does it advance the common good?
- Does it treat everyone the same?
- Does this action violate any of the moral rights of the affected parties?
- Is this action consistent with the moral virtues?
The ethical action is the one that best fits with these 5 approaches.
a) The doctor in this case is facing a conflict between the wife's interest of keeping her
family history secret to save her marriage vs the principles of non-maleficence and
beneficence; to do the best for the upcoming baby.
b) To solve this dilemma, we should ask ourselves 5 ques to know whether the action is
ethical or not:
- What benefit and what harm will this action produce?
- Does it advance the common good?
- Does it treat everyone the same?
- Does this action violate any of the moral rights of the affected parties?
- Is this action consistent with the moral virtues?
The ethical action is the one that best fits with these 5 approaches.
โโโโโโโโโโโ
7_" A drive in school came to a clinic and suffered of epilepsy and wanted the doctor to give him a report that he's medically free and doctor accepted"
A) What are ethical problems related to this case and how to solve it
yourself?
B) What are responsibilities of the physician towards society and humanity
A) What are ethical problems related to this case and how to solve it
yourself?
B) What are responsibilities of the physician towards society and humanity
Answers
โโโ
Ethical Problems:
1. Falsification of Medical Records:
โข Providing a false report that the patient is medically free from epilepsy is unethical and illegal. It compromises the integrity of the medical profession and can have serious consequences for the patient and others.
2. avoid harm to others:
โข Allowing an individual with uncontrolled epilepsy to drive poses a significant risk to public safety. Seizures while driving can lead to accidents, potentially causing harm or death to the driver, passengers, and others on the road.
3. Patientโs Best Interest:
โข Issuing a false report does not serve the patientโs best interest. It may prevent the patient from receiving necessary medical treatment and guidance to manage their condition effectively.
To solve those issues
Honest Communication:
- The doctor should explain to the patient the importance of an accurate medical report and the potential risks associated with driving if their epilepsy is not well-controlled.
2. Proper Assessment:
- Conduct a thorough medical evaluation to determine the patient's current condition and whether they are fit to drive. This includes considering the frequency and severity of seizures, medication adherence, and any recent changes in their health status.
3. Referral to a Specialist:
- If necessary, refer the patient to a neurologist or an epilepsy specialist for further evaluation and management.
4. Legal and Ethical Adherence:
- Follow the legal and ethical guidelines set by medical boards and regulatory bodies regarding reporting and fitness to drive for individuals with epilepsy.
B- Responsibilities towards society and humanity
1- Have an obligation of preserving human life
2- Recognize & deal with unethical behavior of colleagues & health care team. 3- Certify only that which he has verified
4- Provide health care based on wise_& appropriate allocations of limited medical resources (avoid prescribing unnecessary medication, investigation, procedure)
5- Obligation of public reporting of significant, medical hazards (epidemic infection)
6- Oblitogtheahetalthiofosonciety. Participate in all efforts to provide, improve & maintain health care quality for society as a whole.
โโโ
1. Falsification of Medical Records:
โข Providing a false report that the patient is medically free from epilepsy is unethical and illegal. It compromises the integrity of the medical profession and can have serious consequences for the patient and others.
2. avoid harm to others:
โข Allowing an individual with uncontrolled epilepsy to drive poses a significant risk to public safety. Seizures while driving can lead to accidents, potentially causing harm or death to the driver, passengers, and others on the road.
3. Patientโs Best Interest:
โข Issuing a false report does not serve the patientโs best interest. It may prevent the patient from receiving necessary medical treatment and guidance to manage their condition effectively.
To solve those issues
Honest Communication:
- The doctor should explain to the patient the importance of an accurate medical report and the potential risks associated with driving if their epilepsy is not well-controlled.
2. Proper Assessment:
- Conduct a thorough medical evaluation to determine the patient's current condition and whether they are fit to drive. This includes considering the frequency and severity of seizures, medication adherence, and any recent changes in their health status.
3. Referral to a Specialist:
- If necessary, refer the patient to a neurologist or an epilepsy specialist for further evaluation and management.
4. Legal and Ethical Adherence:
- Follow the legal and ethical guidelines set by medical boards and regulatory bodies regarding reporting and fitness to drive for individuals with epilepsy.
B- Responsibilities towards society and humanity
1- Have an obligation of preserving human life
2- Recognize & deal with unethical behavior of colleagues & health care team. 3- Certify only that which he has verified
4- Provide health care based on wise_& appropriate allocations of limited medical resources (avoid prescribing unnecessary medication, investigation, procedure)
5- Obligation of public reporting of significant, medical hazards (epidemic infection)
6- Oblitogtheahetalthiofosonciety. Participate in all efforts to provide, improve & maintain health care quality for society as a whole.
โค1
โโโโโโโโโโโ
8- Name examples of malpractice
Answer
โโโ
Dereliction or negligence (deviation from standard care)
Duty: established physician-patient relation-ship that causes: Damage, injury
- Directly to the patient (by negligence, not another factor)
โโโ
Dereliction or negligence (deviation from standard care)
Duty: established physician-patient relation-ship that causes: Damage, injury
- Directly to the patient (by negligence, not another factor)
โผ๏ธ To show answers just tap on Spoiler area
โค2๐1
PSY
Med Map's
Part 1
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
Dr Effat's
Department's book
1๏ธโฃ Dr Nagi
PlayList in the order of Dr Effat's file
Playlist in the order of Department book
Task: from the 5th to the 8th Video in the playlist
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
2๏ธโฃ MedMap
Medical Psychology 2
Medical Psychology 3
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
Pathology
Written Q For every chapter
Written Q Dr. Eman
Today's task: repair
DR.Elnemr
Files
Med Map's
Part 1
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
Dr Effat's
Department's book
Sources
1๏ธโฃ Dr Nagi
PlayList in the order of Dr Effat's file
Playlist in the order of Department book
Task: from the 5th to the 8th Video in the playlist
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
2๏ธโฃ MedMap
Medical Psychology 2
Medical Psychology 3
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
Pathology
Files
Written Q For every chapter
Written Q Dr. Eman
Sources
Today's task: repair
DR.Elnemr
๐ฅ1
โช Map
Portfolio
Schedule
โญ Revision
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 6
Day 7
โญ Helping Items
โช PSY
โพThe most important written Q for Psychology
โพCancelled Topics
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
โช Anatomy
โพAnatomy Atlases
โพ ุจุตู ุฌุฉ
Portfolio
Schedule
โญ Revision
Day 1
PSY, Patho
Day 2
PSY, Patho
Day 3
PSY, Patho
Day 4
Anatomy, Physiology
Day 5
Anatomy, Physiology
Day 6
Anatomy, Physiology
Day 7
Anatomy, Physiology
โญ Helping Items
โช PSY
โพThe most important written Q for Psychology
โพCancelled Topics
ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู
โช Anatomy
โพAnatomy Atlases
โพ ุจุตู ุฌุฉ
๐ค1
Study Partner 196๐จ๐ปโโ๏ธ๐ฉ๐ปโโ๏ธ pinned ยซโช Map Portfolio Schedule โญ Revision Day 1 PSY, Patho Day 2 PSY, Patho Day 3 PSY, Patho Day 4 Anatomy, Physiology Day 5 Anatomy, Physiology Day 6 Anatomy, Physiology Day 7 Anatomy, Physiology โญ Helping Items โช PSY โพThe most important written Q for Psychologyโฆยป
Study Partner 196๐จ๐ปโโ๏ธ๐ฉ๐ปโโ๏ธ
PSY Files Med Map's Part 1 ููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููููู Dr Effat's Department's book Sources 1๏ธโฃ Dr Nagi PlayList in the order of Dr Effat's file Playlist in the order of Department book Task: from the 5th to the 8th Videoโฆ
๐ ุชู
ุชุญุฏูุซ ู
ุตุงุฏุฑ ู
ูุฏ ู
ุงุจ (ูุฒู ููุฏููููู ุฌุฏุงุฏ).
๐ Cancelled Topics of PSY
ุฃุจุดุฑูุง!
Social psychology (From page 153 till end of book)
(P 69: 74 ูู ู ูุฒู ุฉ ุฏ ุนูุช)
will be MCQ
Sleep (P 53), personality (ู ุด ู ูุฌูุฏุฉ ูู ู ูุฒู ุฉ ุฏ ุนูุช)
ุฃุจุดุฑูุง!
โค4
โค1
II- Communication
1-A 45-year-old female suffering from severe colic, came to the outpatient clinic
surrounded by 5 of her family members. They were upset and worried about her and were
shouting loudly in the clinic. The attending doctor asked most of the family members to get
out of the room, leaving only one person to stay with the patient. This provoked the family
members' anger especially when the physician was using some English medical words, which
they could not understand.
a. What is your point of view concerning the physician's decision? (2 marks)
b. What are the factors that lead to a successful medical interview? (4marks)
c. How to improve your way of giving information during medical interview? (4 marks)
surrounded by 5 of her family members. They were upset and worried about her and were
shouting loudly in the clinic. The attending doctor asked most of the family members to get
out of the room, leaving only one person to stay with the patient. This provoked the family
members' anger especially when the physician was using some English medical words, which
they could not understand.
a. What is your point of view concerning the physician's decision? (2 marks)
b. What are the factors that lead to a successful medical interview? (4marks)
c. How to improve your way of giving information during medical interview? (4 marks)
Answers
โโโ
a) I think the physician decision of letting only one family member be with the patient is
right to maintain discipline in the clinic. But his communication with them was poor
as he used English words while speaking which may affected their understanding of
the situation or they might feel that the doctor was arrogant.
b)
1. Patient related factors:
- Patient's belief of health and illness
- Problem wished to discuss
- Previous experience with medical care
- Current experience with medical care
- Expectations of the doctor will do
- How the patient perceives the role of the doctor
2. Doctor related factors:
- Personality
- Physical factors
- Psychological factors
- Problem wanted to be discussed with patient
- Communication skills
- Self-confidence in the ability to communicate
c)
1. Discuss& clarify every given information.
2. Begin the interview by summarizing the patient's condition.
3. Assess the patient's understanding of the condition.
4. Outline plan of the rest of the interview.
5. Discuss& explain every part of information in appropriate language
6. Mention the most important first
โโโ
right to maintain discipline in the clinic. But his communication with them was poor
as he used English words while speaking which may affected their understanding of
the situation or they might feel that the doctor was arrogant.
b)
1. Patient related factors:
- Patient's belief of health and illness
- Problem wished to discuss
- Previous experience with medical care
- Current experience with medical care
- Expectations of the doctor will do
- How the patient perceives the role of the doctor
2. Doctor related factors:
- Personality
- Physical factors
- Psychological factors
- Problem wanted to be discussed with patient
- Communication skills
- Self-confidence in the ability to communicate
c)
1. Discuss& clarify every given information.
2. Begin the interview by summarizing the patient's condition.
3. Assess the patient's understanding of the condition.
4. Outline plan of the rest of the interview.
5. Discuss& explain every part of information in appropriate language
6. Mention the most important first
โค2
โโโโโโโโโโโ
2- A 35- year- old single lady came to the clinic with continuous vaginal bleeding for
one month. She was terrified from having cancer uterus as she was not yet married. She went
to the gynecologist who suggested a hysterectomy as soon as possible. When she started to
negotiate for other alternatives of management, the doctor replied that he is the specialist
and he is choosing the best for her and otherwise she might lose her life.
a) Based on medical psychology principles; what type of doctor- patient relationship is adopted by
this gynecologist? (2marks)
b) What is your opinion concerning this type of doctor patient relationship? Is there any kind you
prefer in communicating with the patient? (4marks)
c) How would you deliver bad news to the patient? (4marks)
one month. She was terrified from having cancer uterus as she was not yet married. She went
to the gynecologist who suggested a hysterectomy as soon as possible. When she started to
negotiate for other alternatives of management, the doctor replied that he is the specialist
and he is choosing the best for her and otherwise she might lose her life.
a) Based on medical psychology principles; what type of doctor- patient relationship is adopted by
this gynecologist? (2marks)
b) What is your opinion concerning this type of doctor patient relationship? Is there any kind you
prefer in communicating with the patient? (4marks)
c) How would you deliver bad news to the patient? (4marks)
Answers
โโโ
a) This gynecologist adapted the active-passive relationship, in which the patient's role
is completely passive. In this model the doctor wants to lead all the treatment process
without taking into consideration the patient's rights to choose her treatment plan and
to decide what's best for her.
b) I think this model isn't appropriate in this situation as the patient is able to make her
own decision and she has the right to participate in choosing the treatment plan that's
best fits her life style. I also think that doctors shouldn't ignore the patient's opinion
and willingness.
The best doctor-patient relation ship is the rapport model, in which patient and doctor
are cooperative to approach the best for the patient. This model is based on
acceptance, care, empathy, understanding the patient's feelings and problems within a
professional context.
c) Bad news is a relative concept that depends on the patient's interpretation of the
information given and their reaction to it, therefore what's considered bad news for
someone might not be bad news for others. It depends on the patient's personality,
situation and emotions. That's why doctors should consider the individual patient's
needs and circumstances. Doctor needs to be open, honest and provide reassurance
and emotional support to his patients.
โโโ
is completely passive. In this model the doctor wants to lead all the treatment process
without taking into consideration the patient's rights to choose her treatment plan and
to decide what's best for her.
b) I think this model isn't appropriate in this situation as the patient is able to make her
own decision and she has the right to participate in choosing the treatment plan that's
best fits her life style. I also think that doctors shouldn't ignore the patient's opinion
and willingness.
The best doctor-patient relation ship is the rapport model, in which patient and doctor
are cooperative to approach the best for the patient. This model is based on
acceptance, care, empathy, understanding the patient's feelings and problems within a
professional context.
c) Bad news is a relative concept that depends on the patient's interpretation of the
information given and their reaction to it, therefore what's considered bad news for
someone might not be bad news for others. It depends on the patient's personality,
situation and emotions. That's why doctors should consider the individual patient's
needs and circumstances. Doctor needs to be open, honest and provide reassurance
and emotional support to his patients.
โค1