Forwarded from Dr. Thomas Binder, MD
"We conclude that the mRNA vacs dramatically increase inflammation on the endothelium and T cell infiltration of cardiac muscle and may account for the observations of increased thrombosis, cardiomyopathy, and other vascular events following vaccination."
https://t.co/ft6Ike37ze
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.144.suppl_1.10712
https://t.co/ft6Ike37ze
https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.144.suppl_1.10712
Circulation
Abstract 10712: Observational Findings of PULS Cardiac Test Findings for Inflammatory Markers in Patients Receiving mRNA Vaccines…
This clinic has been using the PULS Cardiac Test (Predictive Health Diagnostics Co.,
Irvine, CA) a clinically utilized measurement of multiple protein biomarkers, which
generates a score predicting the 5 yr risk (percentage chance) of a new Acute Coronary…
Irvine, CA) a clinically utilized measurement of multiple protein biomarkers, which
generates a score predicting the 5 yr risk (percentage chance) of a new Acute Coronary…
The title of this paper is self explanatory.
The unvaccinated are NOT a risk to anyone.
No one represents a threat unless symptomatic & even then only if you’re close to them AND susceptible.
It’s an ordinary virus that’s been described with lethality precisely in the range of seasonal influenza.
In those without evident symptoms of respiratory illness, they won’t infect you regardless of vaccination status.
Contrarywise, those WITH symptoms might infect you, again regardless of vaccination status.
There are scores of other respiratory viruses, some with lethality in the same order as SARS-COV-2. You’re not checking for those for no good reason other than you’ve been duped,
Mike
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)02243-1/fulltext
The unvaccinated are NOT a risk to anyone.
No one represents a threat unless symptomatic & even then only if you’re close to them AND susceptible.
It’s an ordinary virus that’s been described with lethality precisely in the range of seasonal influenza.
In those without evident symptoms of respiratory illness, they won’t infect you regardless of vaccination status.
Contrarywise, those WITH symptoms might infect you, again regardless of vaccination status.
There are scores of other respiratory viruses, some with lethality in the same order as SARS-COV-2. You’re not checking for those for no good reason other than you’ve been duped,
Mike
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)02243-1/fulltext
The Lancet
COVID-19: stigmatising the unvaccinated is not justified
In the USA and Germany, high-level officials have used the term pandemic of the unvaccinated,
suggesting that people who have been vaccinated are not relevant in the epidemiology
of COVID-19. Officials’ use of this phrase might have encouraged one scientist…
suggesting that people who have been vaccinated are not relevant in the epidemiology
of COVID-19. Officials’ use of this phrase might have encouraged one scientist…
THE LANCET: COVID-19: stigmatising the unvaccinated is not justified
"In the USA and Germany, high-level officials have used the term pandemic of the unvaccinated, suggesting that people who have been vaccinated are not relevant in the epidemiology of COVID-19. Officials’ use of this phrase might have encouraged one scientist to claim that “the unvaccinated threaten the vaccinated for COVID-19”.
1
But this view is far too simple.
There is increasing evidence that vaccinated individuals continue to have a relevant role in transmission. In Massachusetts, USA, a total of 469 new COVID-19 cases were detected during various events in July, 2021, and 346 (74%) of these cases were in people who were fully or partly vaccinated, 274 (79%) of whom were symptomatic. Cycle threshold values were similarly low between people who were fully vaccinated (median 22·8) and people who were unvaccinated, not fully vaccinated, or whose vaccination status was unknown (median 21·5), indicating a high viral load even among people who were fully vaccinated.
2
In the USA, a total of 10 262 COVID-19 cases were reported in vaccinated people by April 30, 2021, of whom 2725 (26·6%) were asymptomatic, 995 (9·7%) were hospitalised, and 160 (1·6%) died.
3
In Germany, 55·4% of symptomatic COVID-19 cases in patients aged 60 years or older were in fully vaccinated individuals,
4
and this proportion is increasing each week. In Münster, Germany, new cases of COVID-19 occurred in at least 85 (22%) of 380 people who were fully vaccinated or who had recovered from COVID-19 and who attended a nightclub.
5
People who are vaccinated have a lower risk of severe disease but are still a relevant part of the pandemic. It is therefore wrong and dangerous to speak of a pandemic of the unvaccinated. Historically, both the USA and Germany have engendered negative experiences by stigmatising parts of the population for their skin colour or religion. I call on high-level officials and scientists to stop the inappropriate stigmatisation of unvaccinated people, who include our patients, colleagues, and other fellow citizens, and to put extra effort into bringing society together."
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)02243-1/fulltext
"In the USA and Germany, high-level officials have used the term pandemic of the unvaccinated, suggesting that people who have been vaccinated are not relevant in the epidemiology of COVID-19. Officials’ use of this phrase might have encouraged one scientist to claim that “the unvaccinated threaten the vaccinated for COVID-19”.
1
But this view is far too simple.
There is increasing evidence that vaccinated individuals continue to have a relevant role in transmission. In Massachusetts, USA, a total of 469 new COVID-19 cases were detected during various events in July, 2021, and 346 (74%) of these cases were in people who were fully or partly vaccinated, 274 (79%) of whom were symptomatic. Cycle threshold values were similarly low between people who were fully vaccinated (median 22·8) and people who were unvaccinated, not fully vaccinated, or whose vaccination status was unknown (median 21·5), indicating a high viral load even among people who were fully vaccinated.
2
In the USA, a total of 10 262 COVID-19 cases were reported in vaccinated people by April 30, 2021, of whom 2725 (26·6%) were asymptomatic, 995 (9·7%) were hospitalised, and 160 (1·6%) died.
3
In Germany, 55·4% of symptomatic COVID-19 cases in patients aged 60 years or older were in fully vaccinated individuals,
4
and this proportion is increasing each week. In Münster, Germany, new cases of COVID-19 occurred in at least 85 (22%) of 380 people who were fully vaccinated or who had recovered from COVID-19 and who attended a nightclub.
5
People who are vaccinated have a lower risk of severe disease but are still a relevant part of the pandemic. It is therefore wrong and dangerous to speak of a pandemic of the unvaccinated. Historically, both the USA and Germany have engendered negative experiences by stigmatising parts of the population for their skin colour or religion. I call on high-level officials and scientists to stop the inappropriate stigmatisation of unvaccinated people, who include our patients, colleagues, and other fellow citizens, and to put extra effort into bringing society together."
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(21)02243-1/fulltext
The Lancet
COVID-19: stigmatising the unvaccinated is not justified
In the USA and Germany, high-level officials have used the term pandemic of the unvaccinated,
suggesting that people who have been vaccinated are not relevant in the epidemiology
of COVID-19. Officials’ use of this phrase might have encouraged one scientist…
suggesting that people who have been vaccinated are not relevant in the epidemiology
of COVID-19. Officials’ use of this phrase might have encouraged one scientist…
WHAT CAN WE DO? -
DR MIKE YEADON:
We’re doing good stuff here & it’s so important to pick for your use whatever lights you your imagination.
But the key isn’t new info imo.
We’ve way more than we need.
It’s persuading Mattias Desmet’s “go along to get along” 50% that need to be woken up.
The truly deluded I believe are beyond saving at this point. And will throw us under a bus or in jail.
Every one person woken is worth two: one less against us & one more notionally on our side.
Also, make nice to fully vaccinated people who don’t want to boost.
For a brief period, they’re with us: considered unvaccinated.
Finally, I plead for the help of every single one of you who KNOWS this is a giant & evil fraud:
None of us here, least if all me, has the slightest chance on my own of moving the needle.
The more credible one is considered, the more the perpetrators' lackeys focus to smear & suppress such people.
The only way we’ll win this - and we will drive these monsters off eventually - is if all of us take our courage in our hands & GO AND PERSUADE A FEW OTHERS EACH that we’re not at threat from this virus, only it’s supposed remedies.
Please share any tales of success & of new connections to allies made.
Good luck!
Mike
Dr Mike Yeadon
DR MIKE YEADON:
We’re doing good stuff here & it’s so important to pick for your use whatever lights you your imagination.
But the key isn’t new info imo.
We’ve way more than we need.
It’s persuading Mattias Desmet’s “go along to get along” 50% that need to be woken up.
The truly deluded I believe are beyond saving at this point. And will throw us under a bus or in jail.
Every one person woken is worth two: one less against us & one more notionally on our side.
Also, make nice to fully vaccinated people who don’t want to boost.
For a brief period, they’re with us: considered unvaccinated.
Finally, I plead for the help of every single one of you who KNOWS this is a giant & evil fraud:
None of us here, least if all me, has the slightest chance on my own of moving the needle.
The more credible one is considered, the more the perpetrators' lackeys focus to smear & suppress such people.
The only way we’ll win this - and we will drive these monsters off eventually - is if all of us take our courage in our hands & GO AND PERSUADE A FEW OTHERS EACH that we’re not at threat from this virus, only it’s supposed remedies.
Please share any tales of success & of new connections to allies made.
Good luck!
Mike
Dr Mike Yeadon
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Professor Sucharit Bhakdi, retired microbiologist, describes what happens in the vessels following the mRNA jabs.
In June 2020, Corona, False Alarm? exploded into the German market, selling 200,000 copies and 75,000 e-books in the first six weeks.
"In Corona, False Alarm?, award-winning researchers Dr. Sucharit Bhakdi and Dr. Karina Reiss give clarity to these confusing and stressful times. They offer analysis of whether radical protective measures—including lockdown, social distancing, and mandatory masking—have been justified, and what the ramifications have been for society, the economy, and public health. Dr. Bhakdi and Dr. Reiss provide dates, facts, and background information."
https://www.chelseagreen.com/product/corona-false-alarm/
"In Corona, False Alarm?, award-winning researchers Dr. Sucharit Bhakdi and Dr. Karina Reiss give clarity to these confusing and stressful times. They offer analysis of whether radical protective measures—including lockdown, social distancing, and mandatory masking—have been justified, and what the ramifications have been for society, the economy, and public health. Dr. Bhakdi and Dr. Reiss provide dates, facts, and background information."
https://www.chelseagreen.com/product/corona-false-alarm/
Chelsea Green Publishing
Corona, False Alarm? by Sucharit Bhakdi & Karina Reiss
In Corona, False Alarm?, award-winning researchers Dr. Sucharit Bhakdi and Dr. Karina Reiss give clarity to these confusing and stressful times.
Forwarded from Ickonic
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Ickonic's latest original film, A Good Death? Premieres on Sunday 5th December.
We hear the heartbreaking stories from people who have lost loved ones to fatal doses of morphine and midazolam and ask the uncomfortable questions surrounding end of life protocols in our health care institutions.
A Good Death? Premieres December 5th and will be available to all to watch for free on this day.
We hear the heartbreaking stories from people who have lost loved ones to fatal doses of morphine and midazolam and ask the uncomfortable questions surrounding end of life protocols in our health care institutions.
A Good Death? Premieres December 5th and will be available to all to watch for free on this day.
I don’t share many brand new angles but this sounds very interesting.
I’d not noticed the impact of public sector unions but it does look strong.
Trouble is, it’s plausible both that there was collusion (a few well placed calls & promises) or that there wasn’t.
And in the end, I believe we like all others, bar Sweden, were always going to have some degree of lockdown. The timings & amounts were likely unimportant to the global perpetrators.
So I think guy is placing more faith than I have that government would have kept its nerve if public sector unions had been less aggressive.
Cheers
Mike
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o878hwfMKzE
I’d not noticed the impact of public sector unions but it does look strong.
Trouble is, it’s plausible both that there was collusion (a few well placed calls & promises) or that there wasn’t.
And in the end, I believe we like all others, bar Sweden, were always going to have some degree of lockdown. The timings & amounts were likely unimportant to the global perpetrators.
So I think guy is placing more faith than I have that government would have kept its nerve if public sector unions had been less aggressive.
Cheers
Mike
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o878hwfMKzE
YouTube
The Unions and the Coronapanic
This is a remarkable admission if it’s correct.
https://twitter.com/SteveBakerHW/status/1437769574615764992
https://twitter.com/SteveBakerHW/status/1437769574615764992
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
"Any law which violates the inalienable rights of man is essentially unjust and tyrannical; it is not a law at all"
- Maximilien Robespierre
- Maximilien Robespierre
Excerpt:
"Neil Postman, American educator and social philosopher, made very profitable use of McLuhan’s observation to emphasize this particular conflict in terms of printed media vs. the type of visual culture brought about by television (see Postman, 1985). His basic point was that a culture trained almost exclusively by the television medium, will have quite a hard time identifying and understanding the often complex and multi-layered argumentation of refined written exposition. We’re not going to delve into the empirical support for this hypothesis (Mark Bauerlein’s The Dumbest Generation is a good place to start, however), but I trust that the preceding remarks have at least rendered it plausible. So the situation Postman describes implies an immediate vulnerability in the affected population with regard to its ability to effectively and correctly evaluating multi-faceted and ambiguous data. In other words, they’ll not be used to make complex abstract inferences, which written exposition (or a vibrant culture of oral tradition) will train you to do, whereas the passive interaction that characterizes the TV medium and associated forms of communication will train the participant in entirely different ways.
And why is that a problem? Well, a population that on average is ill-suited to handle complex abstractions is not going to be able to creatively organize. It will be easy to govern to the extent that it lacks the ability to scrutinize the precepts and decrees of its rulers, and to understand the social and political processes enveloping it.
It will be easy to propagandize."
https://shadowrunners.substack.com/p/mcluhan-the-peek-a-boo-culture-and
"Neil Postman, American educator and social philosopher, made very profitable use of McLuhan’s observation to emphasize this particular conflict in terms of printed media vs. the type of visual culture brought about by television (see Postman, 1985). His basic point was that a culture trained almost exclusively by the television medium, will have quite a hard time identifying and understanding the often complex and multi-layered argumentation of refined written exposition. We’re not going to delve into the empirical support for this hypothesis (Mark Bauerlein’s The Dumbest Generation is a good place to start, however), but I trust that the preceding remarks have at least rendered it plausible. So the situation Postman describes implies an immediate vulnerability in the affected population with regard to its ability to effectively and correctly evaluating multi-faceted and ambiguous data. In other words, they’ll not be used to make complex abstract inferences, which written exposition (or a vibrant culture of oral tradition) will train you to do, whereas the passive interaction that characterizes the TV medium and associated forms of communication will train the participant in entirely different ways.
And why is that a problem? Well, a population that on average is ill-suited to handle complex abstractions is not going to be able to creatively organize. It will be easy to govern to the extent that it lacks the ability to scrutinize the precepts and decrees of its rulers, and to understand the social and political processes enveloping it.
It will be easy to propagandize."
https://shadowrunners.substack.com/p/mcluhan-the-peek-a-boo-culture-and
shadowrunners
McLuhan, the peek-a-boo-culture, and the modern conditions for propaganda
On propaganda, pt. 1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
The Empty Unconscious
Excerpt:
"The American Dream and Authenticity"
"This cultural underbelly outlined above is eviscerated not just by the corporate art we are confronted with, but by the modern narrative of the American Dream™ ; this statue is just a recent embodiment of it.
Anyone, color and creed aside, through their efforts and ingenuity, can do or be anything they wish to be. No material circumstances obtain in their pursuit of happiness. Class is a byword of another era, trampled underfoot by the ascent of free-market capitalism, which brooks no discriminatory practice in its market-rendered even-playing field.
As any sentient being can observe, this is a historical fiction, a deceit reproduced daily through the channels of mass media and its advertising, entertainment, and news content, all of which is owned and operated by elite capital and managed by its flyblown class of sycophants."
https://cassandravoices.com/society-culture/the-empty-unconscious/
Excerpt:
"The American Dream and Authenticity"
"This cultural underbelly outlined above is eviscerated not just by the corporate art we are confronted with, but by the modern narrative of the American Dream™ ; this statue is just a recent embodiment of it.
Anyone, color and creed aside, through their efforts and ingenuity, can do or be anything they wish to be. No material circumstances obtain in their pursuit of happiness. Class is a byword of another era, trampled underfoot by the ascent of free-market capitalism, which brooks no discriminatory practice in its market-rendered even-playing field.
As any sentient being can observe, this is a historical fiction, a deceit reproduced daily through the channels of mass media and its advertising, entertainment, and news content, all of which is owned and operated by elite capital and managed by its flyblown class of sycophants."
https://cassandravoices.com/society-culture/the-empty-unconscious/
Oct 1, 2021: "AI-powered DoD data analysis program named “Project Salus” SHATTERS official vaccine narrative, shows A.D.E. accelerating in the fully vaccinated with each passing week"
Excerpt:
"An AI-powered Dept. of Defense program named “Project Salus,” run in cooperation with the JAIC (Joint Artificial Intelligence Center), has analyzed data on 5.6 million Medicare beneficiaries aged 65 or older. Data were aggregated from Humetrix, a real-time data and analytics platform that tracks health care outcomes. Legal analysis from Thomas Renz of Renz-Law.com is included in a breaking video interview, below.
The alarming findings show that the vast majority of covid hospitalizations are occurring among fully-vaccinated individuals and that outcomes among the fully vaccinated are growing worse with each passing week. This appears to fit the pattern of so-called Antibody Dependent Enhancement, where the treatment intervention (mRNA vaccines) is worsening health outcomes and leading to excess hospitalizations and deaths.
These data, presented here, shatter the official Biden / Fauci narrative that falsely claims America is experiencing, “a pandemic of the unvaccinated.” The data show that the pandemic actually appears to be accelerated by covid-19 vaccines, while unvaccinated individuals are having far better outcomes than the vaccinated.
Furthermore, according to these data (shown below), the single best strategy for avoid post-vaccine infections and hospitalizations is natural immunity derived from a previous covid infection."
https://www.cracknewz.com/2021/10/breaking-ai-powered-dod-data-analysis.html?m=1
Excerpt:
"An AI-powered Dept. of Defense program named “Project Salus,” run in cooperation with the JAIC (Joint Artificial Intelligence Center), has analyzed data on 5.6 million Medicare beneficiaries aged 65 or older. Data were aggregated from Humetrix, a real-time data and analytics platform that tracks health care outcomes. Legal analysis from Thomas Renz of Renz-Law.com is included in a breaking video interview, below.
The alarming findings show that the vast majority of covid hospitalizations are occurring among fully-vaccinated individuals and that outcomes among the fully vaccinated are growing worse with each passing week. This appears to fit the pattern of so-called Antibody Dependent Enhancement, where the treatment intervention (mRNA vaccines) is worsening health outcomes and leading to excess hospitalizations and deaths.
These data, presented here, shatter the official Biden / Fauci narrative that falsely claims America is experiencing, “a pandemic of the unvaccinated.” The data show that the pandemic actually appears to be accelerated by covid-19 vaccines, while unvaccinated individuals are having far better outcomes than the vaccinated.
Furthermore, according to these data (shown below), the single best strategy for avoid post-vaccine infections and hospitalizations is natural immunity derived from a previous covid infection."
https://www.cracknewz.com/2021/10/breaking-ai-powered-dod-data-analysis.html?m=1
Cracknewz
BREAKING: AI-powered DoD data analysis program named “Project Salus” SHATTERS official vaccine narrative, shows A.D.E. accelerating…
❤2
Wordy but worthy!
Looks like more sleight of hand on testing data was used to justify boosters in Israel.
When the study was done properly, you’re much worse off initially.
In answer to the obvious question: no, there are no honest scientists working for governments.
Mike
Second part to come....
Looks like more sleight of hand on testing data was used to justify boosters in Israel.
When the study was done properly, you’re much worse off initially.
In answer to the obvious question: no, there are no honest scientists working for governments.
Mike
Second part to come....
Forwarded from Ehden's Channel
Booster shots are not effective - part 2 - the cover up:
In response to the publication of the study, which shows that Booster has virtually no epidemiological justification, the Israeli Ministry of Health, which has already been caught rewriting data history on the dashboard, this time completely removed the relevant data and blocked any possibility for independent research
Yariv Hammar, November 2021.
In early October, Prof. Retzaf Levy and Prof. Shoshi Altubia, in collaboration with Oz Koren, published an article indicating that the effectiveness of the booster in preventing infection was much smaller than that found in a study published in September in the New England Journal of Medicie, led by Dr. Sharon Elrai-Price. The study, presented by Dr. Elrai-Price to the FDA, showed that the booster reduces the risk of coronary heart disease by 11.3 times. However, the research of Prof. Levy, Prof. Altuvia and Oz Koren showed that the efficiency is only 1.6. As reported in the research"Real-time news", within 24 hours of the publication of the document containing this dramatic finding by the researchers, the history of the relevant data was rewritten in the control panel of the Ministry of Health, with a sweeping change, months back, of the daily data on positive and unvaccinated positive test rates. In fact, it turned out that the Ministry of Health changed the data retroactively three times. The Ministry of Health has not yet responded to requests for the publication of truth data of Ben Gurion Airport entrants, which were submitted at the time.
According to the researchers, the study led by Elrai-Price suffers from a methodological problem that caused a severe bias - people who did not receive the booster are tested much more than those who received the booster. In order to neutralize the bias and more objectively test the effectiveness of the booster and the green label in preventing infection, they chose to analyze data about a group in which one hundred percent of the people are tested, both vaccinated and unvaccinated - data entering Ben Gurion Airport.
The data were taken from the control panel (dashboard) of the Ministry of Health, which contains details about those entering Ben Gurion Airport according to the number of tests and the number verified, and by segmentation of immunization status - a fact that makes them the best data available. Regarding tests according to the status of immunization, so it is not possible to know what is the general mix of tests and verified according to the status of immunization. It is worth noting that since all those entering Israel undergo a PCR test before their flight to Israel, their chances of leaving positive at Ben Gurion Airport are significantly lower than that of the general population, and therefore the positive percentages are indeed smaller.
As early as October, a decline in the effectiveness of the green label policy could be seen. In light of this, Prof. Retzaf Levy and Oz Koren decided to continue analyzing the data and writing a follow-up article. For this purpose, the number of examinees and the number verified for the vaccinated and unvaccinated who entered Ben Gurion Airport during a period of three months were counted, from August 1, the start date of the booster, until October 30.
The efficiency of the booster is very far from the claims of the Ministry of Health
The findings, which were published on the SSRN pre-publication server, show that in August, 0.65% of the tests among the unvaccinated were positive, compared with 1.59% among the vaccinated - that is, a negative efficiency of 146.46%. In other words, if we were to test the same number of vaccinated and unvaccinated, then for every positive unvaccinated verified, there would be 2.5 vaccinated verified.
In response to the publication of the study, which shows that Booster has virtually no epidemiological justification, the Israeli Ministry of Health, which has already been caught rewriting data history on the dashboard, this time completely removed the relevant data and blocked any possibility for independent research
Yariv Hammar, November 2021.
In early October, Prof. Retzaf Levy and Prof. Shoshi Altubia, in collaboration with Oz Koren, published an article indicating that the effectiveness of the booster in preventing infection was much smaller than that found in a study published in September in the New England Journal of Medicie, led by Dr. Sharon Elrai-Price. The study, presented by Dr. Elrai-Price to the FDA, showed that the booster reduces the risk of coronary heart disease by 11.3 times. However, the research of Prof. Levy, Prof. Altuvia and Oz Koren showed that the efficiency is only 1.6. As reported in the research"Real-time news", within 24 hours of the publication of the document containing this dramatic finding by the researchers, the history of the relevant data was rewritten in the control panel of the Ministry of Health, with a sweeping change, months back, of the daily data on positive and unvaccinated positive test rates. In fact, it turned out that the Ministry of Health changed the data retroactively three times. The Ministry of Health has not yet responded to requests for the publication of truth data of Ben Gurion Airport entrants, which were submitted at the time.
According to the researchers, the study led by Elrai-Price suffers from a methodological problem that caused a severe bias - people who did not receive the booster are tested much more than those who received the booster. In order to neutralize the bias and more objectively test the effectiveness of the booster and the green label in preventing infection, they chose to analyze data about a group in which one hundred percent of the people are tested, both vaccinated and unvaccinated - data entering Ben Gurion Airport.
The data were taken from the control panel (dashboard) of the Ministry of Health, which contains details about those entering Ben Gurion Airport according to the number of tests and the number verified, and by segmentation of immunization status - a fact that makes them the best data available. Regarding tests according to the status of immunization, so it is not possible to know what is the general mix of tests and verified according to the status of immunization. It is worth noting that since all those entering Israel undergo a PCR test before their flight to Israel, their chances of leaving positive at Ben Gurion Airport are significantly lower than that of the general population, and therefore the positive percentages are indeed smaller.
As early as October, a decline in the effectiveness of the green label policy could be seen. In light of this, Prof. Retzaf Levy and Oz Koren decided to continue analyzing the data and writing a follow-up article. For this purpose, the number of examinees and the number verified for the vaccinated and unvaccinated who entered Ben Gurion Airport during a period of three months were counted, from August 1, the start date of the booster, until October 30.
The efficiency of the booster is very far from the claims of the Ministry of Health
The findings, which were published on the SSRN pre-publication server, show that in August, 0.65% of the tests among the unvaccinated were positive, compared with 1.59% among the vaccinated - that is, a negative efficiency of 146.46%. In other words, if we were to test the same number of vaccinated and unvaccinated, then for every positive unvaccinated verified, there would be 2.5 vaccinated verified.
This is the associated piece which goes with the Israeli testing system at Ben Gurion airport.
Thanks
Mike
Thanks
Mike
Forwarded from Ehden's Channel
In September and October the trend was reversed, when in September, 2.03% of the tests among the unvaccinated were positive, compared with 0.59% among the vaccinated - that is, an efficiency of 71%. In October, 0.44% of the tests among the unvaccinated were positive, compared with 0.16% in the vaccinated - an efficiency of 62.43%.
The results of the analysis show that in the overall calculation, over all three months - the protection provided by the booster was about 35%. Among the unvaccinated - 0.98% of the tests were positive, while among the vaccinated - 0.63%. In other words, for every three unvaccinated vertebrae there were approximately two immunized vertebrates.
The expectation of an efficiency of about 91% that emerges from the study of Dr. Elrai-Price and her colleagues at NEJM is thus shattered when examining the Ben Gurion Airport data, which indicated a relative reduction of only 35%. It can also be seen that in the first month of booster administration, the month in which the response to the vaccine was highest, the effectiveness was negative and for each unvaccinated vaccine there were 2.5 times more vaccinated vaccinated - ie exposure to the virus in the first month after the booster endangers vaccinators. In September and October as mentioned the trend reversed, with there being a gradual decline from month to month. At the beginning of November we started to see another decline in the booster efficiency towards the 50% (i.e. for every vaccine there are 2 unvaccinated that stick).
"The data highlight the much problematic nature of the Ministry of Health's optimistic assessments of the effectiveness of vaccines in preventing infections, assessments that have already failed in the past regarding the first two vaccines," says Prof. Levy. "It is a pity that the Ministry of Health does not yet recognize the fact that the role of vaccines is to protect at-risk populations from serious illness, and they will not prevent infection or spread of the virus. In particular, the green label policy has no epidemiological justification, , And the sooner the better!".
The Ministry of Health removed the data
These results are very far from the original claims of the Ministry of Health, according to which the booster effectiveness in preventing infection is very high, and that it reduces the risk of infection in the corona 11.3 times. Against this background, it is hard to be surprised by the announcement by the Director General of the Ministry of Health, Prof. Nachman Ash, yesterday (November 15), that within a month or two they will consider giving another booster, even if no further outburst is seen.
In fact, these findings call into question the entire Green Label policy. In the first month it seems that the green mark is dangerous for those who become infected and more contagious, while in the following months the booster hardly prevents infection, certainly not for a long time. Recall that in a video recording of a conversation between Health Minister Nitzan Horowitz and Interior Minister Ayelet Shaked played by Channel 12 News - a conversation that took place when the two thought the microphones were closed, Minister Horowitz admitted that the purpose of the green label is to encourage booster immunization, not epidemiological considerations.
But surprisingly, a few days after the publication of the study by Prof. Sezaf, Prof. Altuvia and Koren, the Ministry of Health decided for some reason to make a change in the control panel and change the way Ben Gurion Airport data is presented. The data was completely removed completely.
Instead of the segmentation of those entering Ben Gurion Airport according to the status of immunization, a segmentation of incoming Israeli citizens with incoming tourists is now presented. Self-employed people will no longer be able to calculate the effectiveness of vaccines from now on, as reflected in Ben Gurion Airport data. This option was also blocked by the Ministry of Health.
The results of the analysis show that in the overall calculation, over all three months - the protection provided by the booster was about 35%. Among the unvaccinated - 0.98% of the tests were positive, while among the vaccinated - 0.63%. In other words, for every three unvaccinated vertebrae there were approximately two immunized vertebrates.
The expectation of an efficiency of about 91% that emerges from the study of Dr. Elrai-Price and her colleagues at NEJM is thus shattered when examining the Ben Gurion Airport data, which indicated a relative reduction of only 35%. It can also be seen that in the first month of booster administration, the month in which the response to the vaccine was highest, the effectiveness was negative and for each unvaccinated vaccine there were 2.5 times more vaccinated vaccinated - ie exposure to the virus in the first month after the booster endangers vaccinators. In September and October as mentioned the trend reversed, with there being a gradual decline from month to month. At the beginning of November we started to see another decline in the booster efficiency towards the 50% (i.e. for every vaccine there are 2 unvaccinated that stick).
"The data highlight the much problematic nature of the Ministry of Health's optimistic assessments of the effectiveness of vaccines in preventing infections, assessments that have already failed in the past regarding the first two vaccines," says Prof. Levy. "It is a pity that the Ministry of Health does not yet recognize the fact that the role of vaccines is to protect at-risk populations from serious illness, and they will not prevent infection or spread of the virus. In particular, the green label policy has no epidemiological justification, , And the sooner the better!".
The Ministry of Health removed the data
These results are very far from the original claims of the Ministry of Health, according to which the booster effectiveness in preventing infection is very high, and that it reduces the risk of infection in the corona 11.3 times. Against this background, it is hard to be surprised by the announcement by the Director General of the Ministry of Health, Prof. Nachman Ash, yesterday (November 15), that within a month or two they will consider giving another booster, even if no further outburst is seen.
In fact, these findings call into question the entire Green Label policy. In the first month it seems that the green mark is dangerous for those who become infected and more contagious, while in the following months the booster hardly prevents infection, certainly not for a long time. Recall that in a video recording of a conversation between Health Minister Nitzan Horowitz and Interior Minister Ayelet Shaked played by Channel 12 News - a conversation that took place when the two thought the microphones were closed, Minister Horowitz admitted that the purpose of the green label is to encourage booster immunization, not epidemiological considerations.
But surprisingly, a few days after the publication of the study by Prof. Sezaf, Prof. Altuvia and Koren, the Ministry of Health decided for some reason to make a change in the control panel and change the way Ben Gurion Airport data is presented. The data was completely removed completely.
Instead of the segmentation of those entering Ben Gurion Airport according to the status of immunization, a segmentation of incoming Israeli citizens with incoming tourists is now presented. Self-employed people will no longer be able to calculate the effectiveness of vaccines from now on, as reflected in Ben Gurion Airport data. This option was also blocked by the Ministry of Health.