Robin Monotti
66.7K subscribers
15.8K photos
8.75K videos
625 files
30.2K links
Official Robin Monotti Channel
Donations:
robinmonotti.substack.com/
Group is @robinmggroup
We don't DM from this channel account.
Rule: Be polite & respectful.
Download Telegram
8 years on, the Ukrainian crisis is still the West's fault - political scientist

Tuesday, March 15, 2022
 
Uriel Araujo, researcher with a focus on international and ethnic conflicts.

Recently, University of Chicago political science professor John Mearsheimer was the target of yet another "canceling" campaign over his supposed "Putinism". Such was an instance of a larger phenomenon that can be legitimately called a Neo-Mccarthyist Russophobia. The initiative was triggered by the fact that the Russia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs tweeted an endorsement of Mearsheimer's 2014 Foreign Affairs piece called "Why the Ukraine Crisis Is the West’s Fault". Now, the respected American political scientist has responded by writing yet another article for the Economist on the same topic. Before commenting on it, it is worth re-reading the 2014 piece.

In it, Mearshiemer basically argued, 8 years ago, that "the tap root of the trouble is NATO enlargement, the central element of a larger strategy to move Ukraine out of Russia’s orbit and integrate it into the West." The prominent member of the so-called "realist" school of foreign policy also recalled "the EU’s expansion eastward and the West’s backing of the pro-democracy movement in Ukraine—beginning with the Orange Revolution in 2004" as critical elements. Mearsheimer stressed that the illegal overthrow of (pro-Russia) democratically elected Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych, in February 2014, was indeed a "coup", as Russian President Vladmir Putin accurately described it.
In his 2014 article, the political scientist drew attention to the fact that, at the end of the Cold War, Soviet leaders accepted that the US military stayed in Europe. They did not want NATO to expand, however. This in fact was a deal, as declassified documents (that became public in 2017) now shows us: security assurances against any NATO expansion were given by Western leaders to the Soviet authorities, and this "broken promise" is part of the current drama. While the so-called "Iron Curtain" fell, its Western counterpart, NATO, kept on growing aggressively.

Mearsheimer also mentioned the two rounds of NATO's enlargement in 1999 and then in 2004. These angered Moscow, but except for "the tiny Baltic countries", no new NATO member shared a border with Russia yet. Then, the Atlantic Alliance kept moving east: in 2008, it considered admitting Georgia and Ukraine, a move supported by Washington, but opposed by Paris and Berlin (out of fear that doing so would antagonize Russia too much).  The formal process did not start, but NATO issued a statement endorsing Ukrainian and Georgian aspirations.

The piece also reminds us that Victoria Nuland, then U.S. assistant secretary of state for European and Eurasian affairs, estimated in December 2013 that  Washington had invested over $5 billion (since 1991) to help Kiev achieve "the future it deserves." What Mearsheimer described as the "West’s triple package of policies—NATO enlargement, EU expansion, and democracy promotion" created a crisis.

By stating matter-of-factly that efforts to spread Western values and to "promote democracy" often entail "funding pro-Western individuals and organizations", the academic reminds us that there is nothing "neutral" about such idealist initiatives. Throughout the rest of his piece, he further detailed the events pertaining to the 2014 Ukrainian Maidan revolution and stated the undeniable fact that there were neofascist elements amongst the high-ranking members of the new pro-Western Kiev government from the start (an euphemism for Ukraine's Nazi problem, which has only gotten worse).
👍2
Declassified documents show security assurances against NATO expansion to Soviet leaders from Baker, Bush, Genscher, Kohl, Gates, Mitterrand, Thatcher, Hurd, Major, and Woerner

Washington D.C., December 12, 2017 – U.S. Secretary of State James Baker’s famous “not one inch eastward” assurance about NATO expansion in his meeting with Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev on February 9, 1990, was part of a cascade of assurances about Soviet security given by Western leaders to Gorbachev and other Soviet officials throughout the process of German unification in 1990 and on into 1991, according to declassified U.S., Soviet, German, British and French documents posted today by the National Security Archive at George Washington University

The documents show that multiple national leaders were considering and rejecting Central and Eastern European membership in NATO as of early 1990 and through 1991, that discussions of NATO in the context of German unification negotiations in 1990 were not at all narrowly limited to the status of East German territory, and that subsequent Soviet and Russian complaints about being misled about NATO expansion were founded in written contemporaneous memcons and telcons at the highest levels. 
The documents reinforce former CIA Director Robert Gates’s criticism of “pressing ahead with expansion of NATO eastward [in the 1990s], when Gorbachev and others were led to believe that wouldn’t happen.”

The first concrete assurances by Western leaders on NATO began on January 31, 1990, when West German Foreign Minister Hans-Dietrich Genscher opened the bidding with a major public speech at Tutzing, in Bavaria, on German unification. The U.S. Embassy in Bonn (see Document 1) informed Washington that Genscher made clear “that the changes in Eastern Europe and the German unification process must not lead to an ‘impairment of Soviet security interests.’ Therefore, NATO should rule out an ‘expansion of its territory towards the east, i.e. moving it closer to the Soviet borders.’” The Bonn cable also noted Genscher’s proposal to leave the East German territory out of NATO military structures even in a unified Germany in NATO.

This latter idea of special status for the GDR territory was codified in the final German unification treaty signed on September 12, 1990, by the Two-Plus-Four foreign ministers (see Document 25). The former idea about “closer to the Soviet borders” is written down not in treaties but in multiple memoranda of conversation between the Soviets and the highest-level Western interlocutors (Genscher, Kohl, Baker, Gates, Bush, Mitterrand, Thatcher, Major, Woerner, and others) offering assurances throughout 1990 and into 1991 about protecting Soviet security interests and including the USSR in new European security structures. The two issues were related but not the same. Subsequent analysis sometimes conflated the two and argued that the discussion did not involve all of Europe. The documents published below show clearly that it did.
The “Tutzing formula” immediately became the center of a flurry of important diplomatic discussions over the next 10 days in 1990, leading to the crucial February 10, 1990, meeting in Moscow between Kohl and Gorbachev when the West German leader achieved Soviet assent in principle to German unification in NATO, as long as NATO did not expand to the east. The Soviets would need much more time to work with their domestic opinion (and financial aid from the West Germans) before formally signing the deal in September 1990.

As late as March 1991, according to the diary of the British ambassador to Moscow, British Prime Minister John Major personally assured Gorbachev, “We are not talking about the strengthening of NATO.” Subsequently, when Soviet defense minister Marshal Dmitri Yazov asked Major about East European leaders’ interest in NATO membership, the British leader responded, “Nothing of the sort will happen.” (See Document 28)"

https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/briefing-book/russia-programs/2017-12-12/nato-expansion-what-gorbachev-heard-western-leaders-early
How did the Baltic states become independent from the USSR? Through referenda. So why are referenda bad for regions in Ukraine yet good for Baltic states? These double standards are obvious to anybody with a modicum of neutrality.

UK Ambassador in Moscow Rodric Braithwaite diary, 05 March 1991

Tuesday 5 March. The Permanent Representatives in Moscow of the Baltic States come to breakfast Bickauskas Lithuania Peters Latvia and Kahn Estonia Bickauskas is the fiercest He says that yesterday's ratification in the supreme Soviet of the German treaties which was meant to draw a line under the Second World War did no such thing since the Balts - who had lost their freedom because of the war were still not independent He and Peters argued that the West should now formally recognise the independent status of the Baltic states All are very pleased with the results of their various referenda."

https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/media/16142/ocr
👍1
John Major has some explanation to do to the world

UK Ambassador in Moscow Rodric Braithwaite diary, 05 March 1991

"Next we go to meet the Generals Yazov leads the pack and is in fine form He emphasises the value of military exchanges and remarks that this is the first time since the war that East and West have not been afraid of one another Major asks him what professional lessons he draws from the Gulf about the role of armed forces in the new world security situation This gives him a chance to launch into a great harangue about the need for trust and security in Europe which rapidly evolves into a justification of the Soviet position on NATO and the CFE He professes to be worried that the Czechs Poles and Hungarians will join NATO Havel has been making equivocal statements 👉Major assures him that nothing of the sort will happen.👈"

https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/media/16142/ocr
This campaigning group, PANDA, just released a comprehensive assessment of the safety & efficacy of the injectable gene based products.

This is a qualitative assessment, in which basic questions are asked & answered.

Best wishes
Mike

https://www.pandata.org/review-covid-vaccines-oct2022/
Forwarded from Dr. Simon
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
I don't like politicians, which is why I never endorsed any party. However, I consider the Democratic Party in the US quite dangerous. That party is: undemocratic (electoral fraud), globalist, war-mongering, and woke (gender, covid, BLM etc.)

My respect goes to these two brave men standing up against the establishment, and AOC is one of them.

We don't want war. Sending heavy weapons to Ukraine is wrong. Sabotaging pipelines to fuel a war is even worse.

@Goddek
👍1🔥1
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
📣📣📣📣📣📣📣📣📣📣Fully edited video from Tuesday 11 October 2022 - Windsor Vaccine Centre UK 🇬🇧
Mark Sexton, Steve Forsyth and Mikey P all upstanding, peaceful, lawful ex forces/police were arrested and charged for ‘aggravated trespass’ on Public Property whilst trying to close the vaccine centre.
God bless these brave men and women for standing up for humanity and setting an example 🙏
👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇



All the info needed to do this is on our channel
https://t.me/publicannouncement602967921
The sanctions are working as well as the vaccines.
Forwarded from Dr. Simon
Resist big pharma! #BLM
Forwarded from UK Column
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Brian Gerrish, David Scott, Alex Thomson and Debi Evans with Wednesday 12th October 2022 UK Column News.

00:35 - Financial and Economic Chaos
08:21 - Some Lebanese Are Financially More Equal than Others
11:06 - Energy Problems In Germany
14:13 - Tulse Gabbard Accuses Democrats of Ruling for "the Elites"
17:36 - Rob Roos Exposes Pfizer's "Vaccine" Scam
36:14 - The Scottish Independent COVID-19 Inquiry
40:12 - Israel and Palestine Tensions and Death Toll Continues
42:50 - Were British Intelligence Involved In Kerch Bridge Attack?
57:20 - Israel's UK Columns Supporters
58:13 - Alice in Wonderland Investment Zones
59:23 - Remote Frailty Scoring
01:01:25 - UK Column Website Improvements
01:04:58 - Apparent Misinformation From Minister
01:12:19 - Vaccine Victim Seeks Answers from MHRA
01:15:12 - Questions for Derek Thomas MP
01:17:03 - Butterfly Network

Sources: https://www.ukcolumn.org/video/uk-column-news-12th-october-2022
Clips: https://rumble.com/user/UKColumnExtracts
(https://linktr.ee/ukcolumnextracts)
Forwarded from OffGuardian (official)
A COMMENT BTL ON OFFG TODAY -

"Panto season in full swing:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11309551/King-Charles-heard-saying-Dear-oh-dear-greets-Liz-Truss-weekly-audience.html

They’re trying to make Truss the lighning rod for all the anger they know’s out there and in the process damn “toxic libertarianism” (as Hutton put it on the weekend). Then in comes the fuzzy communitarianism to act as cover for the Great Reset pedal to go to the metal. Of course this could also, in the slightly longer term, be turned back against Charles – I wonder if he knows this?

I’ve been suspecting these “hot mic” incidents are staged and certainly this one is."

Agree?

https://off-guardian.org/2022/10/12/pfizer-exec-admits-we-never-tested-vaccine-against-transmission/#comment-548294
I thought exactly the same as the comment above when I saw the video of one of the union leaders at the recent protests suddenly attack libertarianism as if that was the enemy, not the Great Reset.

They are trying to rally the general public against Libertarianism and get Keir Starmer in to strip all our human rights and replace them with the "social universals" thought up at the MIT media lab as a substitute for the benefit of Big Tech and the oligarchy as a whole.

Robin

https://youtu.be/t39kQjcXD5M
Forwarded from The Vigilant Fox 🦊
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
'The Greater Good': Where Did This Term Come From and Does It Actually Serve?

Robin Monotti: "I think there is an effort that is coordinated across these institutions that I mentioned [WEF, Google, and so on] to shift from what we know or knew of as human rights to a new concept called 'social universals' ... to change all of what we know as human rights, effective[ly], to strip them away from us."

Podcast Host: t.me/jermwarfare

@VigilantFox | Rumble | Full Video
👍1
Forwarded from Together Declaration
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Would you have done things differently @sajidjavid ?

"No!" he says then attempts to justify based on 'facts'

See video below for the ‘facts’

Mandate was entirely wrong & v damaging

Staff lost, beds blocked, rights trampled

Apologise Reinstate Compensate 40K+ staff

Please share this & sign the letter:

https://togetherdeclaration.org/care/
I wasn’t aware of significant use of remdesivir in UK. That’s as much my failing as the lack of general disclosure of protocols beyond what was once known as the Liverpool Care Pathway.
Used without compassion & in a heartless, formulaic way, it’s medical murder. In tens of thousands of people, all support was removed, in many cases even water, while midazolam & morphine were ramped up. In some cases it seems remdesivir was also administered, and this has a marked negative effect on kidney function. Many elderly people have reduced kidney function before entering their final period of life, and so it’s utterly indefensible to be giving it to patients.

Best wishes
Mike
World War One As A Proto-Great Reset

Occasionally people say that we "sleepwalked" into World War One.

Well, in some ways, we did because we had not got the technology to offer a different narrative than the elites: country against country, etc.

However, it is more appropriate to consider WW1 as a proto-Great Reset.

Can we wake up from the sleepwalk before we reach the edge of the cliff this time?

We should all try to disturb the sleepwalkers I think. The price to pay for not doing that can be too big to not give it a try.

Let's stop the sleepwalkers.

Robin

"Building on the work of the historian Arno Mayer and others, Pauwels argues the First World War was not simply a war between states, it was also a war between social classes. It was “wanted and unleashed by a European elite” of aristocrats and capitalists who saw in war a means to reverse the growing democratization of society that threatened their position and power."

The Great Class War 1914-1918 – Jacques Pauwels
https://www.jacquespauwels.net/the-great-class-war-1914-1918/
It seems clear now that NATO, led by the U.S., is willing to escalate a European war if that’s what it takes to protect the climate change goals.

"Without Russia as the bad guy, the Build Back Better agenda becomes naked to the world. The Ukraine conflict provides a visible shield to prevent any larger discussion, as evidenced by the attempt by Elon Musk to mitigate the Ukraine conflict by talking about a peace deal wherein Russia keeps the Russian speaking eastern Ukraine. In the week since that proposal became international fodder for ridicule, the conflict in Ukraine has intensified. This is not coincidental.

We are pretending our way into a war."

https://www.lifesitenews.com/opinion/the-real-reason-biden-is-escalating-americas-involvement-in-the-russia-ukraine-war/?utm_source=telegram
The Great Climate Change War

This could be just the beginning of a totally different level of warfare, which we then cannot protest against. Once we are controlled we cannot protest against even bigger atrocities than the total elimination of human rights within the population with regards to bodily autonomy.

There are other stages beyond this. This is a stepping stone.

And I’m worried that what’s after this could be a lot worse. It links in with the whole issue of the New Energy supply chains, which will require militarization (which now has been privatised: you have private military throughout Africa).

At some stage they’ll face resistance. So that’s when maybe that the big guns come out.

And I think this is why the current situation is happening before the full implementation of the whole new "green" economy which is being prepared, because I think that that requires a level of militarization and war which the public is not ready for.

Robin

Contributions from 18 September 2021, part 4: Robin Monotti - Left Lockdown Sceptics
https://leftlockdownsceptics.com/2021/10/contributions-from-18-september-part-4-robin-monotti/