I saw mention of this emergency declaration in a Substack article & thought to look it up.
I’m not suggesting you read all 31 pages but a couple of questions that immediately came to mind as I leafed through it were:
1. Was this really written from scratch in 1Q2020? If so, what was it about a respiratory illness that prompted the form and meat of it?
2. Under what prior emergency situation would it ever have been considered necessary to have the extent of the powers contemplated in this Order? The seizure of private property including full title to said property is no more or less a doctrine expoused by Karl Marx. What the dickens is it doing in a place like Illinois?
You’ll likely have your own reactions.
What you probably won’t experience is “Oh yes, I can see how this made perfect sense, given the nature of the concerns of the day”.
I wonder if the general public was aware what had happened in terms of the granting of truly dictatorial powers by a notionally democratically elected local leader, their antennae might have been pinged?
Why not try, share with normies, asking them why in their view this is entirely reasonable. It’d be interesting watching them try, and fail, to make any sense of this :)
Best wishes
Mike
https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.townnews.com/wandtv.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/5/51/551ced24-6535-11ea-9826-4f4fd396dacb/5e6b960454b21.pdf.pdf
I’m not suggesting you read all 31 pages but a couple of questions that immediately came to mind as I leafed through it were:
1. Was this really written from scratch in 1Q2020? If so, what was it about a respiratory illness that prompted the form and meat of it?
2. Under what prior emergency situation would it ever have been considered necessary to have the extent of the powers contemplated in this Order? The seizure of private property including full title to said property is no more or less a doctrine expoused by Karl Marx. What the dickens is it doing in a place like Illinois?
You’ll likely have your own reactions.
What you probably won’t experience is “Oh yes, I can see how this made perfect sense, given the nature of the concerns of the day”.
I wonder if the general public was aware what had happened in terms of the granting of truly dictatorial powers by a notionally democratically elected local leader, their antennae might have been pinged?
Why not try, share with normies, asking them why in their view this is entirely reasonable. It’d be interesting watching them try, and fail, to make any sense of this :)
Best wishes
Mike
https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.townnews.com/wandtv.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/5/51/551ced24-6535-11ea-9826-4f4fd396dacb/5e6b960454b21.pdf.pdf
👍1
Forwarded from David Kurten
The government's behavioural psychology 'nudge unit' is working overtime to get people to accept energy cuts for the 'net-zero' ideology, instead of developing our onshore and offshore gas supplies and lifting sanctions on Russia so we can buy Russian gas to keep the lights on this winter.
Forwarded from Peter A. McCullough, MD, MPH™
How Pfizer and Moderna used Weber Shandwick to Push Vaccines on the CDC | Pfizer has used Weber Shandwick as a longstanding PR vendor for a variety of pharmaceutical and vaccine products. In 2020, Weber Shandwick began PR and marketing activities for Moderna. This was around the time the marketing firm was awarded a federal contract from the CDC. Recently Weber Shandwick was caught secretly operating an embedded marketing unit within the CDC National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases and this was called out by a letter from Senator Rand Paul on October 24, 2022. #courageousdiscourse https://www.americaoutloud.com/stories-of-corruption-cast-a-dark-shadow-post-covid-and-q-a-46-on-america-out-loud-pulse/
America Out Loud News
Stories of Corruption Cast a Dark Shadow Post-COVID and Q & A 46 on America Out Loud PULSE - America Out Loud News
America Out Loud PULSE with Dr. Peter McCullough and Malcolm Out Loud – I distrust Pharma, period. That begs the question: To receive the flu shot this year or not? Should I still be concerned about potential heart scarring? Would the presence and persistence…
Forwarded from The Daily Sceptic
Dramatic Recovery in Global Sea Ice Confounds the Net Zero Catastrophists
➥ Read this article
@LockdownSceptics
➥ Read this article
@LockdownSceptics
The Daily Sceptic
Dramatic Recovery in Global Sea Ice Confounds the Net Zero Catastrophists – The Daily Sceptic
When global sea ice dropped sharply 10 years ago, there was no end of stories of the coming climate catastrophe. But the more recent dramatic recovery in sea ice has gone strangely unmentioned and ignored.
😁1
Is Fossil Fuel Actually Produced Renewably Inside the Earth? Some Scientists Theorize ‘Abiotic’ Origins of Oil
"Most people are taught that petroleum is formed deep under the Earth over the course of millions of years and is derived from the remains of plankton, plants, and other biological organisms. This explanation is stated matter-of-factly on certain government and educational websites.
This theory for oil formation is, however, just that—a theory. There is an opposing view that has substantial evidence to back it up.
Credence for oil’s organic origin (biotic origin) is strong in the United States, while the idea of an inorganic origin (abiotic origin) has long been accepted among post-Soviet scientists. Some American scientists have also jumped on the abiotic train, scorned though it may be by most of their peers.
They point to problems posed by the idea that oil comes from dead plants.
When a plant or animal dies, very little of its matter is buried. Nature recycles—some of nature’s greatest recyclers are insects, microorganisms, fungi, and bacteria. Has enough organic matter really been buried below the Earth to create trillions of barrels of oil?
Moreover, the biotic theory holds that organic matter must fit within the “oil window” before becoming oil. The oil window refers to a set of conditions, including reaching a particular depth (1 to 2.5 miles) where the temperature is right (140 to 300 degrees Fahrenheit) for oil to be produced.
Proponents of the alternative, abiotic theory, say oil may instead be a primordial substance that rises up from the Earth’s depths through fissures. Thus, oil might originate independently of organic sources undergoing chemical processes, similar to how methane is found on asteroids or in other barren environments.
Skeptics say methane is a simpler substance than petroleum; the process of forming the hydrocarbons in petroleum is more complex and the same logic might not hold."
https://www.theepochtimes.com/is-fossil-fuel-actually-produced-renewably-inside-the-earth-some-scientists-theorize-abiotic-origins-of-oil_4882472.html
"Most people are taught that petroleum is formed deep under the Earth over the course of millions of years and is derived from the remains of plankton, plants, and other biological organisms. This explanation is stated matter-of-factly on certain government and educational websites.
This theory for oil formation is, however, just that—a theory. There is an opposing view that has substantial evidence to back it up.
Credence for oil’s organic origin (biotic origin) is strong in the United States, while the idea of an inorganic origin (abiotic origin) has long been accepted among post-Soviet scientists. Some American scientists have also jumped on the abiotic train, scorned though it may be by most of their peers.
They point to problems posed by the idea that oil comes from dead plants.
When a plant or animal dies, very little of its matter is buried. Nature recycles—some of nature’s greatest recyclers are insects, microorganisms, fungi, and bacteria. Has enough organic matter really been buried below the Earth to create trillions of barrels of oil?
Moreover, the biotic theory holds that organic matter must fit within the “oil window” before becoming oil. The oil window refers to a set of conditions, including reaching a particular depth (1 to 2.5 miles) where the temperature is right (140 to 300 degrees Fahrenheit) for oil to be produced.
Proponents of the alternative, abiotic theory, say oil may instead be a primordial substance that rises up from the Earth’s depths through fissures. Thus, oil might originate independently of organic sources undergoing chemical processes, similar to how methane is found on asteroids or in other barren environments.
Skeptics say methane is a simpler substance than petroleum; the process of forming the hydrocarbons in petroleum is more complex and the same logic might not hold."
https://www.theepochtimes.com/is-fossil-fuel-actually-produced-renewably-inside-the-earth-some-scientists-theorize-abiotic-origins-of-oil_4882472.html
The Epoch Times
Is Fossil Fuel Actually Produced Renewably Inside the Earth? Some Scientists Theorize ‘Abiotic’ Origins of Oil
If a person is open minded enough to review this graph (checking some of the sources to be sure that the data are well supported by reliable evidence), I believe it wouldn’t be possible to maintain any kind of belief in the “we’re in a climate emergency” narrative.
You’ll notice the complete lack of relationship between atmospheric CO2 concentrations and temperature.
Best wishes
Mike
You’ll notice the complete lack of relationship between atmospheric CO2 concentrations and temperature.
Best wishes
Mike
Give the gift of Health and Safety this holiday season to your friends, family members, co-workers and strangers on the street. This trendy medical alert bracelet is our unified way to say no to harmful drugs without going to Court.
Bi-partisan power of the people, yes we mean you! The bracelet says you are
Allergic to: Remdesivir, Barticinib and Fentanyl.
Hospitals cannot ignore this medical directive.
The hospitals and their employees have been pushing these deadly drugs because they are making enormous amounts of money. Big pharma buys expensive ads causing the networks and their affiliates to keep quiet when reporting the news. We can unite and force big pharma and hospitals to stop using these expensive deadly drugs.
The medical alert bracelet is your directive in case you are unable to speak for yourself if you have to go to the hospital. It’s a Tax deductible gift when purchased through through FormerFedsGroup.org. We are taking preorders now for delivery in two weeks. Demand is high so take advantage of the preorder by emailing CC at Former Feds
1 Your name
2 Address for delivery
3 Quantity (see pricing below)
4 Please put MAB in memo part of email
5 You will receive an auto response confirming receipt of your email and a link to make your payment which is deductible as a charitable donation.
Email to: Carolyn.Blakemen@FormerFedsGroup.org
$25 for one medical alert bracelet. $20 per bracelet when you purchase five or more in one order.
The bracelet is a silicone band with a stainless steel buckle and plate, laser engraved. Turn it over it looks like a cool stylish bracelet. A conversation starter with strangers. Buy extras and hand them out to strangers and save lives this holiday season.
We already have pre-orders so if you want yours in time for the holidays order today.
Let’s make this the new ice bucket challenge. Let’s save the world from death by hospital and pharma protocols. Proceeds will help fund the class action on behalf of the thousands of victims killed by these protocols. The class action is Primarily seeking a cease and desist order from the Court. The Court could award disgorgement but the focus of the surviving family members is mostly to prevent others meeting the same painful and inhumane fate.
Thank you for your support. Stay healthy and safe
Jamie Scher
Bi-partisan power of the people, yes we mean you! The bracelet says you are
Allergic to: Remdesivir, Barticinib and Fentanyl.
Hospitals cannot ignore this medical directive.
The hospitals and their employees have been pushing these deadly drugs because they are making enormous amounts of money. Big pharma buys expensive ads causing the networks and their affiliates to keep quiet when reporting the news. We can unite and force big pharma and hospitals to stop using these expensive deadly drugs.
The medical alert bracelet is your directive in case you are unable to speak for yourself if you have to go to the hospital. It’s a Tax deductible gift when purchased through through FormerFedsGroup.org. We are taking preorders now for delivery in two weeks. Demand is high so take advantage of the preorder by emailing CC at Former Feds
1 Your name
2 Address for delivery
3 Quantity (see pricing below)
4 Please put MAB in memo part of email
5 You will receive an auto response confirming receipt of your email and a link to make your payment which is deductible as a charitable donation.
Email to: Carolyn.Blakemen@FormerFedsGroup.org
$25 for one medical alert bracelet. $20 per bracelet when you purchase five or more in one order.
The bracelet is a silicone band with a stainless steel buckle and plate, laser engraved. Turn it over it looks like a cool stylish bracelet. A conversation starter with strangers. Buy extras and hand them out to strangers and save lives this holiday season.
We already have pre-orders so if you want yours in time for the holidays order today.
Let’s make this the new ice bucket challenge. Let’s save the world from death by hospital and pharma protocols. Proceeds will help fund the class action on behalf of the thousands of victims killed by these protocols. The class action is Primarily seeking a cease and desist order from the Court. The Court could award disgorgement but the focus of the surviving family members is mostly to prevent others meeting the same painful and inhumane fate.
Thank you for your support. Stay healthy and safe
Jamie Scher
This is what humanity is up against.
That temperature graph is problematic. Ask yourself why the baseline period was chosen. It’s the coldest few decades of the current cycle. Current cycle, what do I mean? Temperature has cycled by a low, single digit number of centigrade repeatedly in the past millennium, according to proxies. Nothing unusual is happening.
The strong claim that it’s pretty much definitely CO2 release, by humans, that’s caused the warming, is also problematic. CO2 has been MUCH higher in the past and is NOT linked to temperature. There’s no uncertainty about it.
We do have a better explanation for the absolutely standard warming of late, solar output cycles.
According to those who study solar cycling, and the impact upon earths climate, we’re heading into a grand solar minimum, which is expected to be accompanied by a FALL in global temperatures.
But reading those scores of organizations, all lying to you & taking the Thunberg school of “climate science”, makes me afraid. Why are there so few scientists from those societies, perhaps recently retired ones, speaking out?
They’d better, because I am not authoritative about this & don’t plan to try to be.
Best wishes
Mike
https://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus.amp
That temperature graph is problematic. Ask yourself why the baseline period was chosen. It’s the coldest few decades of the current cycle. Current cycle, what do I mean? Temperature has cycled by a low, single digit number of centigrade repeatedly in the past millennium, according to proxies. Nothing unusual is happening.
The strong claim that it’s pretty much definitely CO2 release, by humans, that’s caused the warming, is also problematic. CO2 has been MUCH higher in the past and is NOT linked to temperature. There’s no uncertainty about it.
We do have a better explanation for the absolutely standard warming of late, solar output cycles.
According to those who study solar cycling, and the impact upon earths climate, we’re heading into a grand solar minimum, which is expected to be accompanied by a FALL in global temperatures.
But reading those scores of organizations, all lying to you & taking the Thunberg school of “climate science”, makes me afraid. Why are there so few scientists from those societies, perhaps recently retired ones, speaking out?
They’d better, because I am not authoritative about this & don’t plan to try to be.
Best wishes
Mike
https://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus.amp
Climate Change: Vital Signs of the Planet
Scientific Consensus: Earth's Climate is Warming
Vital Signs of the Planet: Global Climate Change and Global Warming. Partial list of leading scientific organizations endorsing human-induced climate change, along with a selection of related resources.
Forwarded from Dr. Simon
"Excess COVID deaths were not caused by the virus which is seasonal and not mitigated by social distancing “measures”. Excess all-cause deaths resulted from interference with natural defences that rely on sunlight exposure and social interactions as well as a thriving economy."
Exactly! :)
https://metatron.substack.com/p/did-the-covid-virus-kill-anyone
Exactly! :)
https://metatron.substack.com/p/did-the-covid-virus-kill-anyone
Dead Man Talking
Did the COVID Virus Kill Anyone?
Evidence to support the "fragile healthcare hypothesis" and genetic "vaccine" mediated incidence of infection and disease, without which there may have been no unusual excess death in Europe.
Forwarded from Spirit of Liberty
The Club of Rome and the Rise of the “Predictive Modelling” Mafia
While many are now familiar with the manipulation of predictive modelling during the COVID-19 crisis, a network of powerful Malthusians have used the same tactics for the better part of the last century in order to sell and impose their agenda.
"While much propaganda has gone into convincing the world that eugenics disappeared with the defeat of Hitler in 1945, the reality, as I discussed in my previous article The Revenge of the Malthusians and the Science of Limits, is far removed from this popular fantasy.
In that piece, I reviewed the origins of cybernetics as a new 'science of control' created during World War II by a nest of followers of Lord Bertrand Russell who had one mission in mind. This mission was to shape the thinking of both the public as well as a new managerial elite class who would serve as instruments for a power they were incapable of understanding…"
👉 Read more: Unlimited Hangout
While many are now familiar with the manipulation of predictive modelling during the COVID-19 crisis, a network of powerful Malthusians have used the same tactics for the better part of the last century in order to sell and impose their agenda.
"While much propaganda has gone into convincing the world that eugenics disappeared with the defeat of Hitler in 1945, the reality, as I discussed in my previous article The Revenge of the Malthusians and the Science of Limits, is far removed from this popular fantasy.
In that piece, I reviewed the origins of cybernetics as a new 'science of control' created during World War II by a nest of followers of Lord Bertrand Russell who had one mission in mind. This mission was to shape the thinking of both the public as well as a new managerial elite class who would serve as instruments for a power they were incapable of understanding…"
👉 Read more: Unlimited Hangout
Forwarded from Spirit of Liberty
The Foreign Data Set Was Gutted This Week in VAERS and the Cancer Signal Was Halved, the Myocarditis Dose 3 Response Signal Was Lost and 994 Spontaneous Abortions/Still Births Were Dropped
For starters…
"As most of you know, me and a bunch of other people are monitoring VAERS data very closely week-by-week. This week (11.18.22), the first thing I noticed was that the Foreign data set was less than a fraction of the size it was last week (11.11.22): down from 283.51MB to 96.81MB. There is a disclaimer under the VAERS data, so this is not mistake
I decided to process the data as I always do on Fridays.
The first thing I do when I analyze the VAERS data (after downloading) is compile the Domestic data set. Then I compile the Foreign data set. Then I merge them along with the 2021 COVID-19 data. Then I count the numbers of VAERS IDs in both and do some basic descriptive statistics - like how many males versus females, age demographics, dose data and more…"
👉 Read more: Jessica Rose
For starters…
"As most of you know, me and a bunch of other people are monitoring VAERS data very closely week-by-week. This week (11.18.22), the first thing I noticed was that the Foreign data set was less than a fraction of the size it was last week (11.11.22): down from 283.51MB to 96.81MB. There is a disclaimer under the VAERS data, so this is not mistake
I decided to process the data as I always do on Fridays.
The first thing I do when I analyze the VAERS data (after downloading) is compile the Domestic data set. Then I compile the Foreign data set. Then I merge them along with the 2021 COVID-19 data. Then I count the numbers of VAERS IDs in both and do some basic descriptive statistics - like how many males versus females, age demographics, dose data and more…"
👉 Read more: Jessica Rose
❤1
Forwarded from DELIVERING LIBERTY
Reactions of locals and workers at the Oxfordshire County Council 15min Neighbourhoods/Smart Cities for climate alarmism
Cancer specialist says Covid boosters are harming his patients
"PROFESSOR Angus Dalgleish, a consultant medical oncologist at St George’s, University of London, has put out a urgent call for a halt to all Covid vaccine programmes. Very simply, they are not needed and they are doing significant harm, and not just with regard the blood clots and cardiac problems. The boosters are having a devastating impact on his cancer patients.
As a practising oncologist I am seeing people with stable disease rapidly progress after being forced to have a booster, usually so they can travel.
‘Even within my own personal contacts I am seeing B cell-based disease after the boosters. They describe being distinctly unwell a few days to weeks after the booster – one developing leukaemia, two work colleagues Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and an old friend who has felt like he has had Long Covid since receiving his booster and who, after getting severe bone pain, has been diagnosed as having multiple metastases from a rare B cell disorder.
‘I am experienced enough to know that these are not the coincidental anecdotes that many suggest, especially as the same pattern is being seen in Germany, Australia and the USA.
‘The reports of innate immune suppression after mRNA for several weeks would fit, as all these patients to date have melanoma or B cell based cancers, which are very susceptible to immune control – and that is before the reports of suppressor gene suppression by mRNA in laboratory experiments.
‘This must be aired and debated immediately.’
https://www.conservativewoman.co.uk/cancer-specialist-says-covid-boosters-are-harming-his-patients/
"PROFESSOR Angus Dalgleish, a consultant medical oncologist at St George’s, University of London, has put out a urgent call for a halt to all Covid vaccine programmes. Very simply, they are not needed and they are doing significant harm, and not just with regard the blood clots and cardiac problems. The boosters are having a devastating impact on his cancer patients.
As a practising oncologist I am seeing people with stable disease rapidly progress after being forced to have a booster, usually so they can travel.
‘Even within my own personal contacts I am seeing B cell-based disease after the boosters. They describe being distinctly unwell a few days to weeks after the booster – one developing leukaemia, two work colleagues Non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, and an old friend who has felt like he has had Long Covid since receiving his booster and who, after getting severe bone pain, has been diagnosed as having multiple metastases from a rare B cell disorder.
‘I am experienced enough to know that these are not the coincidental anecdotes that many suggest, especially as the same pattern is being seen in Germany, Australia and the USA.
‘The reports of innate immune suppression after mRNA for several weeks would fit, as all these patients to date have melanoma or B cell based cancers, which are very susceptible to immune control – and that is before the reports of suppressor gene suppression by mRNA in laboratory experiments.
‘This must be aired and debated immediately.’
https://www.conservativewoman.co.uk/cancer-specialist-says-covid-boosters-are-harming-his-patients/
The Conservative Woman
Cancer specialist says Covid boosters are harming his patients - The Conservative Woman
❤1
https://www.conservativewoman.co.uk/cancer-specialist-says-covid-boosters-are-harming-his-patients/
A major cancer scientist calls for complete abandonment of the genetic injections.
Expect more suppression.
My comment below the article, in case it gets suppressed.
Best wishes
Mike
A major cancer scientist calls for complete abandonment of the genetic injections.
Expect more suppression.
My comment below the article, in case it gets suppressed.
Best wishes
Mike
Forwarded from NBD Europe official
HART
Right of reply in BJM
“Dear Editor,
HART comprises a group of volunteer professionals, doctors and scientists unequivocally committed to evidence-based policy making and the precautionary principle. We have no external funding. We believe that high quality science is aided by debate and argument and thank the BMJ for the opportunity to respond. We found the employment of baseless smears, innuendo and guilt by association against HART and others to be disappointing, unhelpful and unprofessional.
We formed HART in response to the dominant narrative that coalesced early during the pandemic before much data was available. Our goal is to test, challenge and question aspects of that narrative in the highest traditions of scientific discourse. We fully support effective and safe vaccines. We are in favour of practical and evidence-based public health measures.
We have publicly raised concerns about vaccination mandates and certificates, the public health impact of lockdown measures, zero-covid targets, masking effectiveness and harms, vaccination of post-infected persons, school closures and vaccinating children to protect adults, amongst other issues that should give pause to serious policy makers planning for future pandemics. We have been surprised to have been met with highly personalised attempts to discredit us rather than mature scientific debate.
We believe many of our concerns will turn out to be justified in the long term, and possibly sooner. As in any scientific debate, we of course recognise that some of our genuine concerns may turn out to have been misplaced as further evidence emerges. We disagree with the proposal that any “contrarian messages” should not “be able to influence policy”. We further disagree with the idea of “revoking the license [sic] to practise” in order to “punish doctors” who raise questions about public health policy, in good faith, in public discourse.
We regard the article as a transparent and quite unsubtle paradigm of a technique they themselves unashamedly promote called “prebunking” (the use of “persuasive but false argument to trigger the [informational] ‘immune system’”). It is littered with evangelism, invective, hysteria and hyperbole constituting, ironically, misinformation in our view. We trust that cooler heads will prevail at the formal inquiry.
For the avoidance of doubt, and with a gentle eye-roll, we point out that we have not made any claims about “bioweapons facilities” in Wuhan, “5G technology having deleterious effects”, or that Bill Gates had “foreknowledge of the pandemic” nor claimed “miracle cures” for covid exist.
HART were among the first to raise concerns about vaccine side effects (including myo/pericarditis, clotting issues and death), overdiagnosis in the post-infectious period and the failure of vaccines to prevent infection. These were all smeared as “misinformation” - all are now widely accepted as true.
We deplore abandoning core ethical principles such as adults having a duty to protect children, informed consent and bodily autonomy. We do not understand why the expert formal UK pandemic plan, effectively implemented by Sweden, was swiftly abandoned and replaced by snap decision-making predicated on panic and fear.
We recall the Health Secretary stating in the House of Commons: “This vaccine will not be used on children, it hasn’t been tested on children and the reason is that the likelihood of children having significant detriment if they catch covid is very very low.” [1]
We are not sure why this sensible policy was subsequently ditched.
In conclusion, we again thank the BMJ for the opportunity to refute the groundless allegations made in the article above and invite readers to draw their own conclusions as to the credibility of authors who struggle to evidence many of the, frankly, wild claims they make against HART group and others.”
https://www.bmj.com/content/379/bmj-2022-070331/rr-5
Right of reply in BJM
“Dear Editor,
HART comprises a group of volunteer professionals, doctors and scientists unequivocally committed to evidence-based policy making and the precautionary principle. We have no external funding. We believe that high quality science is aided by debate and argument and thank the BMJ for the opportunity to respond. We found the employment of baseless smears, innuendo and guilt by association against HART and others to be disappointing, unhelpful and unprofessional.
We formed HART in response to the dominant narrative that coalesced early during the pandemic before much data was available. Our goal is to test, challenge and question aspects of that narrative in the highest traditions of scientific discourse. We fully support effective and safe vaccines. We are in favour of practical and evidence-based public health measures.
We have publicly raised concerns about vaccination mandates and certificates, the public health impact of lockdown measures, zero-covid targets, masking effectiveness and harms, vaccination of post-infected persons, school closures and vaccinating children to protect adults, amongst other issues that should give pause to serious policy makers planning for future pandemics. We have been surprised to have been met with highly personalised attempts to discredit us rather than mature scientific debate.
We believe many of our concerns will turn out to be justified in the long term, and possibly sooner. As in any scientific debate, we of course recognise that some of our genuine concerns may turn out to have been misplaced as further evidence emerges. We disagree with the proposal that any “contrarian messages” should not “be able to influence policy”. We further disagree with the idea of “revoking the license [sic] to practise” in order to “punish doctors” who raise questions about public health policy, in good faith, in public discourse.
We regard the article as a transparent and quite unsubtle paradigm of a technique they themselves unashamedly promote called “prebunking” (the use of “persuasive but false argument to trigger the [informational] ‘immune system’”). It is littered with evangelism, invective, hysteria and hyperbole constituting, ironically, misinformation in our view. We trust that cooler heads will prevail at the formal inquiry.
For the avoidance of doubt, and with a gentle eye-roll, we point out that we have not made any claims about “bioweapons facilities” in Wuhan, “5G technology having deleterious effects”, or that Bill Gates had “foreknowledge of the pandemic” nor claimed “miracle cures” for covid exist.
HART were among the first to raise concerns about vaccine side effects (including myo/pericarditis, clotting issues and death), overdiagnosis in the post-infectious period and the failure of vaccines to prevent infection. These were all smeared as “misinformation” - all are now widely accepted as true.
We deplore abandoning core ethical principles such as adults having a duty to protect children, informed consent and bodily autonomy. We do not understand why the expert formal UK pandemic plan, effectively implemented by Sweden, was swiftly abandoned and replaced by snap decision-making predicated on panic and fear.
We recall the Health Secretary stating in the House of Commons: “This vaccine will not be used on children, it hasn’t been tested on children and the reason is that the likelihood of children having significant detriment if they catch covid is very very low.” [1]
We are not sure why this sensible policy was subsequently ditched.
In conclusion, we again thank the BMJ for the opportunity to refute the groundless allegations made in the article above and invite readers to draw their own conclusions as to the credibility of authors who struggle to evidence many of the, frankly, wild claims they make against HART group and others.”
https://www.bmj.com/content/379/bmj-2022-070331/rr-5
The BMJ
In defence of evidence-based policy making
👍2