Ignoring the Evidence
A historical perspective on the germ versus terrain argument
Andrew Barr
"In my last Substack article, a review of Jenny Goodman’s new book Getting Healthy in Toxic Times, I criticised the tendency of many of us in the freedom movement to abandon critical thinking and to proceed from understanding that government and media are lying to us to automatically assuming that whatever is the opposite of the official narrative must necessarily be the truth.
Nowhere is this process more evident than in the popularity within the freedom movement of the ‘terrain’ theory of disease. Because we have been lied to from the beginning about the origins and virulence of COVID-19, and about how best to protect ourselves, many in the movement have gone to the opposite extreme and argued that no such disease as COVID-19 exists, and indeed that no such malady could ever have existed because the entire concept of infectious disease is a fallacy, and that when people exhibit what have been traditionally described as symptoms of an infectious illness, they are in fact detoxing chemicals from their system.
I do have views on the detox issue but I won’t be going into them here, as I’m not a medical expert. I have no intention of examining the terrain theory on medical or scientific grounds, but rather on the basis of history.
READ LINK FOR HISTORICAL COMMENTARY
One reason why members of the freedom movement so often quarrel about the terrain versus germ theory issue is that they’re arguing at cross-purposes, having failed to define terms. Many proponents of the terrain theory do insist, like Lester and Parker, that there’s no such thing as an infectious disease. But others simply believe that the terrain is more important than the germ, and that if people look after themselves, eat healthily, get plenty of fresh air and exercise, and maintain their emotional and spiritual wellbeing, they’re much less likely to succumb to an infectious disease. When one talks of the terrain versus germ debate, one does need to make it clear to which version of the argument one is referring.
I’d place myself in the second category, among those who believe the terrain is more important than the germ. The histories of the Black Death and the destruction of the Amerindians by smallpox support this version of the theory by demonstrating that people who have been weakened by poor nutrition or oppressive working conditions are more likely to succumb to an infectious disease. The argument that the terrain is more important than the germ is the corollary of the contention that cases of infectious disease have declined principally because of better health and living conditions rather than because of vaccination or antibiotics.
I’ve tried to show why, from an historical perspective, I think that the ‘fundamentalist’ version of the terrain theory is nonsense – the argument that nobody has ever died from an infectious disease, because these illnesses have never existed. From a political perspective, my concern with the widespread support for this theory within the freedom movement is that it gives ammunition to our opponents and makes it easier for them to ridicule us for not thinking rationally – which is of course exactly what we accuse them of doing. We need to be better than them, not the mirror image."
Andrew Barr
https://stiffnecked.substack.com/p/ignoring-the-evidence
ROBINMG ✍
A historical perspective on the germ versus terrain argument
Andrew Barr
"In my last Substack article, a review of Jenny Goodman’s new book Getting Healthy in Toxic Times, I criticised the tendency of many of us in the freedom movement to abandon critical thinking and to proceed from understanding that government and media are lying to us to automatically assuming that whatever is the opposite of the official narrative must necessarily be the truth.
Nowhere is this process more evident than in the popularity within the freedom movement of the ‘terrain’ theory of disease. Because we have been lied to from the beginning about the origins and virulence of COVID-19, and about how best to protect ourselves, many in the movement have gone to the opposite extreme and argued that no such disease as COVID-19 exists, and indeed that no such malady could ever have existed because the entire concept of infectious disease is a fallacy, and that when people exhibit what have been traditionally described as symptoms of an infectious illness, they are in fact detoxing chemicals from their system.
I do have views on the detox issue but I won’t be going into them here, as I’m not a medical expert. I have no intention of examining the terrain theory on medical or scientific grounds, but rather on the basis of history.
READ LINK FOR HISTORICAL COMMENTARY
One reason why members of the freedom movement so often quarrel about the terrain versus germ theory issue is that they’re arguing at cross-purposes, having failed to define terms. Many proponents of the terrain theory do insist, like Lester and Parker, that there’s no such thing as an infectious disease. But others simply believe that the terrain is more important than the germ, and that if people look after themselves, eat healthily, get plenty of fresh air and exercise, and maintain their emotional and spiritual wellbeing, they’re much less likely to succumb to an infectious disease. When one talks of the terrain versus germ debate, one does need to make it clear to which version of the argument one is referring.
I’d place myself in the second category, among those who believe the terrain is more important than the germ. The histories of the Black Death and the destruction of the Amerindians by smallpox support this version of the theory by demonstrating that people who have been weakened by poor nutrition or oppressive working conditions are more likely to succumb to an infectious disease. The argument that the terrain is more important than the germ is the corollary of the contention that cases of infectious disease have declined principally because of better health and living conditions rather than because of vaccination or antibiotics.
I’ve tried to show why, from an historical perspective, I think that the ‘fundamentalist’ version of the terrain theory is nonsense – the argument that nobody has ever died from an infectious disease, because these illnesses have never existed. From a political perspective, my concern with the widespread support for this theory within the freedom movement is that it gives ammunition to our opponents and makes it easier for them to ridicule us for not thinking rationally – which is of course exactly what we accuse them of doing. We need to be better than them, not the mirror image."
Andrew Barr
https://stiffnecked.substack.com/p/ignoring-the-evidence
ROBINMG ✍
Stiff-Necked: the journal of a dissident Jew, by Andrew Barr
Ignoring the Evidence
A historical perspective on the germ versus terrain argument
❤25👍20🤔4🔥1😁1💯1🤪1
Insider Paper
BREAKING: Large fire at BioLab in Conyers, Georgia sends massive plume of smoke over sky, I-20 being blocked off, residents told to leave Follow @insiderpaper
CHEMICAL LOCKDOWN
NEW: Georgia’s Rockdale County has ordered 90,000 residents to “shelter-in-place” indefinitely.
The EPA and state-level EPD testing has confirmed chlorine is being vaporized and spread throughout the region.
Americans 20 miles away are reporting smelling chlorine in the air. Highway traffic will be impacted, while ports are going on strike.
October Surprises have begun."
https://x.com/DiedSuddenly_/status/1840752266350879104
ROBINMG ✍
NEW: Georgia’s Rockdale County has ordered 90,000 residents to “shelter-in-place” indefinitely.
The EPA and state-level EPD testing has confirmed chlorine is being vaporized and spread throughout the region.
Americans 20 miles away are reporting smelling chlorine in the air. Highway traffic will be impacted, while ports are going on strike.
October Surprises have begun."
https://x.com/DiedSuddenly_/status/1840752266350879104
ROBINMG ✍
👍33🤨13🙏4❤1
Forwarded from InfoDefenseENGLISH
Left photo:
Yesterday, at the Babi Yar memorial, Zelensky was conveniently Jewish. Over 33,000 Jews were slaughtered by the Nazis at Babi Yar between 1941 and 1943.
Right photo:
A year ago, Zelensky was conveniently Nazi, honoring a 98-year-old SS-man who took part in the slaughter of Jews.
For the U.S. and the neoliberal West, Zelensky is a perfectly convenient rubber puppet—no principles, no shame, no conscience.
📱 InfoDefenseENGLISH
📱 InfoDefense
Yesterday, at the Babi Yar memorial, Zelensky was conveniently Jewish. Over 33,000 Jews were slaughtered by the Nazis at Babi Yar between 1941 and 1943.
Right photo:
A year ago, Zelensky was conveniently Nazi, honoring a 98-year-old SS-man who took part in the slaughter of Jews.
For the U.S. and the neoliberal West, Zelensky is a perfectly convenient rubber puppet—no principles, no shame, no conscience.
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
💯57👍10🤬4😐4❤2😱1
InfoDefenseENGLISH
Left photo: Yesterday, at the Babi Yar memorial, Zelensky was conveniently Jewish. Over 33,000 Jews were slaughtered by the Nazis at Babi Yar between 1941 and 1943. Right photo: A year ago, Zelensky was conveniently Nazi, honoring a 98-year-old SS-man who…
A "perfectly convenient rubber puppet—no principles, no shame, no conscience."?
Sounds like Keir Starmer!
📱 ROBINMG
Sounds like Keir Starmer!
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
💯63👍7
UK Medical Freedom Alliance: Broadcast #28 - Dr Liz Evans - Northern Ireland Public Health Bill
https://rumble.com/v5gf3ed-uk-medical-freedom-alliance-broadcast-28-dr-liz-evans-northern-ireland-publ.html
📱 ROBINMG
https://rumble.com/v5gf3ed-uk-medical-freedom-alliance-broadcast-28-dr-liz-evans-northern-ireland-publ.html
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Rumble
Dr Liz Evans - Important Statement re. The Northern Ireland Public Health Bill
Disclaimer: https://rumble.com/v6056un-ukmfa-disclaimer.html Dr Liz Evans makes an important statement on behalf of UKMFA regarding the Northern Ireland Public Health Bill which would give unprecedent
🤬1
Ireland To Arrest Citizens Who Refuse mRNA Shots During ‘Future Pandemics’
The Irish government has vowed to mass arrest citizens who refuse to take the mRNA jabs during the next pandemic.
"The government of Northern Ireland is currently running a public consultation on the Public Health Bill – a law that, if passed, will allow authorities to detain citizens and forcibly inject them with experimental vaccines."
https://thepeoplesvoice.tv/ireland-to-arrest-citizens-who-refuse-mrna-shots-during-future-pandemics/
📱 ROBINMG
The Irish government has vowed to mass arrest citizens who refuse to take the mRNA jabs during the next pandemic.
"The government of Northern Ireland is currently running a public consultation on the Public Health Bill – a law that, if passed, will allow authorities to detain citizens and forcibly inject them with experimental vaccines."
https://thepeoplesvoice.tv/ireland-to-arrest-citizens-who-refuse-mrna-shots-during-future-pandemics/
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
The People's Voice
Ireland To Arrest Citizens Who Refuse mRNA Shots During ‘Future Pandemics’
The Irish government has vowed to mass arrest citizens who refuse to take the mRNA jabs during the next pandemic.
🤬79😡70🤔6😱5❤3🤯3🔥1🙏1
PEACE AND FREEDOM RALLY USA
Roger Waters, Scott Ritter, Andrew Napolitano, Randy Credico, Joe Lauria and Gerald Celente spoke live from Kingston, New York on Saturday. Watch the full replay.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03oxDt3H2G0
📱 ROBINMG
Roger Waters, Scott Ritter, Andrew Napolitano, Randy Credico, Joe Lauria and Gerald Celente spoke live from Kingston, New York on Saturday. Watch the full replay.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03oxDt3H2G0
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
YouTube
[REMOTE] - Occupy, Peace & Freedom Rally - Kingston, NY (Special Guests!)
Join Us for the Occupy Peace & Freedom Rally - September 28th!
Four Corners of Freedom, John St. & Crown St ., Kingston, NY
- STREAMING LIVE - for those who can't be there in person!
Saturday, September 28th, don’t miss a powerful gathering…
Four Corners of Freedom, John St. & Crown St ., Kingston, NY
- STREAMING LIVE - for those who can't be there in person!
Saturday, September 28th, don’t miss a powerful gathering…
👍38❤9⚡2
US Deploys a ‘Few Thousand’ More Troops To Middle East - Bloomberg
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-09-30/us-deploys-a-few-thousand-more-troops-to-middle-east
📱 ROBINMG
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-09-30/us-deploys-a-few-thousand-more-troops-to-middle-east
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Bloomberg.com
US Deploys a ‘Few Thousand’ More Troops to Middle East
The US is deploying a few thousand more troops to the Middle East to defend Israel as the country steps up attacks against Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Pentagon said.
🤬45🤔10🔥1
Forwarded from Health Ranger
Near-nationwide outage of Verizon now hitting. Also getting reports that some AT&T phones are locked in "SOS" mode. Someone is taking down the comms infrastructure. A good reminder to always have backup comms. Meanwhile, all ports from Texas, across the entire East Coast will be closed starting tomorrow due to the strike. Until resolved, all inbound shipping transport will go to zero. This is going to get ugly.
🙏41👍5❤3😱1😢1
Robin Monotti
CHEMICAL LOCKDOWN NEW: Georgia’s Rockdale County has ordered 90,000 residents to “shelter-in-place” indefinitely. The EPA and state-level EPD testing has confirmed chlorine is being vaporized and spread throughout the region. Americans 20 miles away are…
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
😱19🙏9🤬7❤3🤔2😭2👍1
Robin Monotti
Ireland To Arrest Citizens Who Refuse mRNA Shots During ‘Future Pandemics’ The Irish government has vowed to mass arrest citizens who refuse to take the mRNA jabs during the next pandemic. "The government of Northern Ireland is currently running a public…
⚠️ NORTHERN IRELAND - draconian new Public Health Bill proposed (Paul Frew...
https://youtube.com/watch?v=pLoBwa8_1xU&feature=shared
📱 ROBINMG
https://youtube.com/watch?v=pLoBwa8_1xU&feature=shared
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
YouTube
⚠️ NORTHERN IRELAND - draconian new Public Health Bill proposed (Paul Frew MLA)
Well done Paul Frew, Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA), for challenging & raising awareness
If you're in N Ireland pls get on to your MLA today, here's how: https://togetherdeclaration.org/ni
If you're in N Ireland pls get on to your MLA today, here's how: https://togetherdeclaration.org/ni
👍44❤8🤬8😱1
Forwarded from LauraAboli (Laura Aboli)
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
“F*ck Macron, F*ck all globalists, F*ck all these motherf*cking globalists, They try to push a political and corrupt agenda...”
Brazilian fighter Renato Moicano after winning his bout at UFC last night in Paris.
An awakened fighter!
😃😂😁
https://t.me/LauraAbolichannel
Brazilian fighter Renato Moicano after winning his bout at UFC last night in Paris.
An awakened fighter!
😃😂😁
https://t.me/LauraAbolichannel
👍102❤26👏19😁4🏆2
Rachel Reeves ‘war on pensioners’ continues with £16bn tax raid ‘considered'
https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1955045/retirement-rachel-reeves-pensions
📱 ROBINMG
https://www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1955045/retirement-rachel-reeves-pensions
Please open Telegram to view this post
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Express.co.uk
Rachel Reeves ‘war on pensioners’ continues with £16bn tax raid ‘considered'
The Chancellor may consider charging employers National Insurance for retirement contributions in October's Budget, according to pensions consultancy firm Lane Clark & Peacock (LCP).
🤬35😡3❤1